Also, I'm sure I have a dozen restore password emails in GMail somewhere. And I'm sure I'm not alone.
Maybe that should be the next Google Labs feature. The 'Mission Impossible' option. (i.e. 'this message will self-destruct')
Database of Christian dating site logins -> Same password as email -> Same password as Facebook and/or use email to reset
In general, if someone can read your email, they can steal almost any of your accounts. Are email accounts generally that insecure? I trust any major Webmail provider to not steal my bank account, but is trust the only thing really keeping our bank accounts secure?
If we really are that insecure, then people are probably going to attack your bank account long before they attack your random web-app account. If your site isn't guarding valuables, it's probably perfectly "safe" to send authentication tokens in mail messages. No?
Maybe I'm reading this wrong, but isn't most email encryption done with GPG/PGP or S/MIME? Where do client-side SSL certificates come in?
If you are going to do this right, you need email encryption. In which case, you have a client-side certificate. In which case, you might as well just authenticate over SSL with that certificate.
But hey, why do something secure and built-in to every browser (even IE) when you can invent your own protocol instead? It's the Internet!
Also, any reason why this is an "Ask HN" and not a blog post? (Not saying it should be one or the other... just askin'.)