If you're talking about the ability to write a novel, I agree with you. But you have to learn how to get your thoughts down on paper in a way that is intelligible by other humans, and that's a technical skill that must be learned through repetition and critique. There's a basic technical skill to writing long form content, and many kids don't get it because their teacher doesn't have time to grade 140 papers.
Re:The Big Problem with the New SAT
by saint_fiasco on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @05:02PM
(#9494949)
Colleges aren't looking for successful authors. They look for people who communicate well in writing.
I think the top writers didn't need attention from their English teachers, but the fairly good ones probably did.
There's no way I'd ever buy that. Writing ability is largely correlated to the amount of time the student spends reading... reading novels, instruction manuals, technical books, Web pages, and cereal boxes. Teachers have almost nothing to do with it in my experience, and I think you'll find that any successful author will tell you exactly the same thing.