News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Retire This Idea: Scientific Knowledge Structured as “Lit... by kijin on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @01:09AM (#9490943)
Exactly. The problem is that papers aren't worth what the rest of the world think they are. Nobody who is working on the cutting edge of a given field give a damn about the papers that are published in the field's major journals. Papers are little more than permanent records of what people talked about at some conference several months before, and through other informal channels even earlier. By the time they're published, they're already old news. They may be worth some archival value, but that's about it.

Unfortunately, the rest of the world thinks of papers as the primary method by which scientists exchange ideas. This is a myth. Sure, there some scientists (mostly in developing countries, or those coming from a different field) who rely on papers to figure out what their colleagues are up to, but if so, that's only a reason to improve real-time communication, not a reason to turn papers into real-time communication tools.

Re:Retire This Idea: Scientific Knowledge Structured as “Lit... by christudor on Tuesday May 05, 2015 @04:13AM (#9491396)
This and the previous comment are /exactly/ right, especially: "... that's only a reason to improve real-time communication, not a reason to turn papers into real-time communication tools".