Re:Police Start to Reconsider Longstanding Rules on Using Force
by mcintyre1994 on Monday May 04, 2015 @06:37PM
(#9489717)
Yea, tasers seem superior by pretty much any measure to shooting to immobilise. The only advantage I can see a gun having is range, and far outside taser range I don't think trying to shoot a leg is exactly reasonable.
They don't of course solve the problem of police using too much force for the situation - they're nasty and threatening at a peaceful protest for instance, but when the force is appropriate they seem like a no brainer.
Re:Police Start to Reconsider Longstanding Rules on Using Force
by htns on Monday May 04, 2015 @06:34PM
(#9489705)
Here in Finland armed men getting shot in the leg is not that rare of an occurrence, e.g. http://yle.fi/uutiset/prison_guard_arrested_after_shooting_a...
Re:Police Start to Reconsider Longstanding Rules on Using Force
by kevinnk on Monday May 04, 2015 @07:10PM
(#9489830)
The question here is what did the police aim for not what did they hit.
Re:Police Start to Reconsider Longstanding Rules on Using Force
by vacri on Monday May 04, 2015 @08:02PM
(#9490075)
In that video, the man with the knife is not threatening the police or rushing them. He wasn't even reacting to the policeman walking close by. Not to say that the UK don't have a different policing style, but that video isn't an example of police behaviour when being rushed.
That sounds more like a movie than "Western Europe." Nobody shoots at legs since it is ineffective, can end their life anyway, and can risk collateral damage (what is behind that leg? What if the bullet bounces off of the bone?). You shoot to kill, period.
Here's what the UK police do: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vf3RZ7gi2f0
Which is exceptional policing in my opinion. But no shooting at his leg.
PS - Not disagreeing with the argument that US police are too quick to kill people, even unarmed people. Just that shooting at people's legs is a legitimate alternative. Even when armed, other countries kill citizens much more rarely.
PPS - Another good video showing UK police's constraint, this time armed officers: https://youtu.be/nVOLH_aN-zI?t=3m35s contrast that with this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wwYVJ4W7DPo both incidents involve a cap gun and armed police (one in the US one in the UK).