Eventually, the block reward will be very small and transaction fees will be the only profit miners make. So you're basically paying the miners to protect the network by verifying the transactions.
IIRC this is only because some generous folks run miners willing to process zero-fee transactions in order to clean them up and forgive those who probably made the transaction fee too small in error. What if they decide to stop upgrading their equipment to keep up with the difficulty?
Edit: It's the age of the inputs to the transaction, not the age of the transaction itself that counts. But it's possible to just wait until the transaction inputs are old and then the transaction will go through.
Transaction fees are necessary for the same fundamental reason why bitcoin works at all - proper incentives. If there were no incentive to mine, miners wouldn't do it. The block reward will gradually step to 0, and won't be the primary source of mining income long before that. Transaction fees are the long term solution for miners to get paid. They also create a disincentive for people to create unnecessary transactions which would bloat the blockchain.
So far I don't think there has been anything that makes actually processing transactions cheaper (maybe moving to levelDB from berkelyDB would count), but I think that part is essentially trivial anyway.
If there were high bandwidth costs for mining that would work in the favor of centralization, but I don't think the cost of processing a transaction or the bandwidth are anywhere near being a bottleneck. Processing transactions seems likely to never be more than trivial but I don't know that much about it.
No, centralisation proceeds because the hashing is subject to economies of scale.
If processing power increases, it increases for all players.
I'm not sure I follow. If processing the block-chain is cheap enough that everybody can do it, I see no reason to depend entirely on centralized mines. The little guy can still participate, and there's bound to be more little guys than big guys, especially if bitcoin clients do a bit of mining themselves.
Sure, it's profitable and large-scale operations will probably arise, but that's distinct from centralization, per se.
Now we've come full-circle to my original thesis: this is a short-term phenomenon that I predict will slow and eventually reverse.
I'm still unclear as to why this shouldn't be the case.
> Also, computing power per watt requires ASICs to compete.
EDIT (since I can no longer reply): ASICs should only offset the point at which it becomes feasible for common-denominator computers to participate. I fear we may be talking past each other...
Bitcoin mining started on general-purpose CPUs. Then people discovered they could compute more hashes per watt on GPUs. Then people realised that a custom circuit optimised just to perform that calculation would be most efficient, starting with FPGAs and then burning those circuits into ASICs.
All mining that is feasible these days is done with specially-built ASICs, and even then the cost of mining 1 BTC (hardware and electricity) is hovering around 1 BTC.
Isn't this a non-issue in the long-run due to Moore's law? Even if centralization happens in the short-run as a result of processing expenses, everything is destined to become decentralized as processing power increases.
>Transaction fees
Could someone please explain why transaction fees are deemed necessary?