The problem is that the existence of that one issue demonstrates a serious failure in the tools and development processes and quality checks used to create the control software. There could therefore be other issues in the code that haven't been found yet that could cause similarly catastrophic failures.
Failing to reliably identify this kind of arithmetic error is a huge deal when you're working with high-reliability software. It simply shouldn't happen, and there should have been several different stages in the development process that would have prevented it.
So, the development team should have the book thrown at them until someone figures out exactly how it did happen, closes every related tool and process loophole so it can never happen again, and audits all potentially affected code to make sure the same combination of loopholes hasn't allowed any similar mistakes into production elsewhere in the system.
I have some production code that uses ints as serial numbers with a factory method that just hands out the next one in sequence, however, I take care to ensure that there will be no negative consequences if they roll over (they exist only in debug builds).