Re:What we know about the EmDrive and Cannae Drive
by btilly on Monday May 04, 2015 @02:25PM
(#9488042)
When you say, "If you run the numbers", what you mean is, "If you do the calculation for the operation that we know how to do then..."
And I agree. We do not know how to perform an operation that extracts net energy from the zero point energy. We have no idea how to go about it. And we have good reason to suspect that this is impossible.
We just have no proof of it.
For an analogy to a past situation like this, it is like the situation for many decades when it was known that Maxwell's demon could break the laws of entropy, but we were pretty sure it couldn't be built. And there was a century long back and forth on the topic before that was demonstrated.
Yes, that's because if you arrange stuff in a "vacuum" it's no longer a vacuum. In the case of the Casimir effect, you now have a pair of uncharged plates in what used to be vacuum.
The question is, how do you propose to extract net energy using this effect? It takes energy to arrange the stuff in the first place (for example, to put the uncharged plates in place)--in other words, it takes energy to perturb the "vacuum". If you run the numbers, you'll see that there's no way to get back more energy from something like the Casimir effect than it took to arrange the stuff the right way in the first place. Which is just another way of saying that the "zero point" of an actual vacuum--no stuff present at all--is still effectively the lowest energy you can achieve.