The other day, a user posted a topic in a sub-forum I follow. I cited the sub-forum's criteria and recommended posting elsewhere. The admins agreed, killing the post. The user responded with floral appreciation for the admins stewardship and bowed out.
Detecting something was off, I checked the user's post-history. I discovered he'd pivoted into this elaborate troll routine, crafting well-made Photoshopped summary screenshots, baiting the admins into commenting, then parsing and sub-parsing their comments with disregard for truth, all the while he cross-posted his progress with a "counter-culture" sub-forum to get their approval.
It struck me as a lonely exercise for him, however, it seemed like he was seeking an outlet for his creativity. Looking back, it's almost as if what happened didn't even matter, he could/would run the same routine.
One of the things I love about HN is that there are so many Really Fucking Smart People® with something interesting to say that flaming [along with inside jokes] constitutes some of the least interesting content. Indeed HN has even suppressed snark.
I think a big part of why trolling appealed to me is simply an appreciation of surreal humor and situations. As an example, secretly installing a bidet in the shared men's restroom. That, to me, is the positive way to behave trollishly - putting people in strange situations and seeing what happens.
Someone actually beat another person in the face over who would get to buy Tickle Me Elmo or the latest Harry Potter book? I found stuff like that really disgusting, and I wanted them to feel disgusted, too. I wanted them to think about how disgusting they were.
Over the years, as I got a little better control over my mind and feelings, I stopped behaving like that. I realize now that my behavior was not constructive, and I'm sorry. But I couldn't just know what was at the end of that road without walking it.
I think I'm extremely un-sadistic. If anything, I'm unusually empathetic. And I don't enjoy, much less need, attention. If anything, I'm unusually motivated by my internal self-assessment. I know from times when other members of the troll gang I was in would break character that I'm not the only (former) troll of this type.
There seems to be an idea flying around lately that trolling is just a safe, cowardly way of being sadistic, but I find that really simplistic. In some cases trolling seems closer to a weird kind of performance art by people with surplus brain cycles, motivation, initiative, and creativity.