Re:Library of Babel
by recursive on Sunday May 03, 2015 @01:06PM
(#9482061)
On average, the link would be at least as long as the book.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I think yk's idea is excellent - I'm actually working on it right now. You're correct that the book locations need to be about as long as the book to provide sufficient unique values - but it isn't humanly or temporally possible for people to bookmark that many pages - so a separate index of bookmarked pages could use much shorter urls.
Re:Library of Babel
by anotheryou on Sunday May 03, 2015 @04:58PM
(#9483009)
and please make the bookmarks unguessable and private.
I want to sent moderately private letters, that where already "written" in the library :)
I'm glad you suggested that - will do.
Re:Library of Babel
by anotheryou on Friday May 15, 2015 @10:56AM
(#9551024)
letters where sent :)
I'm still amazed at the project, thank you
Not if you let the first linked page be site.com/1, the next one site.com/2 and so on, I think.
Yes, even then.
Sure "1" and "2" are pretty short. And even "57834573495879436129386943" is pretty short.
But the average link would have so many digits, I couldn't post it in this comment.
The bookmarks would only need to map to the book locations - you would only need sufficient values for the number of bookmarked pages, not the entire range of possibilities.