Re:Cops: We Need Rights More Than You, Citizen
by jdreaver on Saturday May 02, 2015 @11:11PM
(#9479654)
I agree.
When we talk about government and big business propping each other up, I don't want to get into the chicken and egg problem of whose fault it really is (if such a thing could even be defined). I just like to address the fact that whatever the cause, government mixing with big business is not capitalism. In fact, part of the definition of capitalism the absence of government.
I guess I just get confused when people point out things that are failures of the state, blame capitalism, and then go on to blame profit, or owning businesses and capital. Indeed, part of the beauty of a free market is the power of choice. When you make all decisions through a central authority, you lose that power of choice.
um... who do you think makes fighter jets ?
Re:Cops: We Need Rights More Than You, Citizen
by mbrubeck on Sunday May 03, 2015 @01:48AM
(#9480154)
I think Retric's point was that private companies are supposed to make fighter jets, but they often fail to produce usable results. See the now-decade-old F-35 program for the latest example.
It's not about who makes it, it's about who buys it. And nobody but the government buys fighter jets, so it is effectively not a private enterprise. It's just contracted government work. There's really no competing consumer.
But to be clear private companies do a great job making shoes. Lots of evedence suggests they do a poor job at making fighter jets. The problem is clearly incentives. Less well known there are also issues with private companies making army boots. And again the problem seems to be capitalism only applies when lots of little choices are being made, if each private chose his own boot from say 5 companies you would expect much better outcomes vs the current approach.
IMO, you can only call it capitolism when the government buys the same products as any other person on the market. As soon as one person is making a multi million dollar deal you lose feedback that keeps the system in check and are forced to rely on regulations. IMO, this means government contractors are inherently a bad idea.