News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by icelancer on Saturday May 02, 2015 @07:26PM (#9478962)
What? They are allowed to express their right to free speech and expression as well, just as the protestors should be able to.
Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by agwa on Saturday May 02, 2015 @08:26PM (#9479174)
Legally, they do not have the right of free speech when in uniform. See Garcetti v. Ceballos: http://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=6711908971660042...

And as a matter of principle, they should not. When in uniform, a police officer is not a private person, who has rights, but rather a representative of the government, which does not have rights, but authority delegated to it by the people.

Further reading, from an actual lawyer: http://blog.simplejustice.us/2014/10/18/ferguson-revenge-of-...

Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by eru on Saturday May 02, 2015 @09:19PM (#9479340)
> And as a matter of principle, they should not. When in uniform, a police officer is not a private person, who has rights, but rather a representative of the government, which does not have rights, but authority delegated to it by the people.

Oh, they still have rights when in uniform. Eg at the most basic, the right not to be killed. But you are right about the free speech. Just like any other employee in their capacity as an employee, only more so.

Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by vacri on Saturday May 02, 2015 @10:08PM (#9479481)
Neither of your links support your case.

In the first link, the case is about a memo written as part of the employee's role; a uniform is irrelevant (district attorneys don't wear uniforms, and the word 'uniform' is mentioned zero times in the document).

In the second link, the article explicitly states: "Wearing a badge doesn’t forfeit the free speech of the person". It's abundantly clear that these police turning their backs on the mayor at a funeral over a political stoush between the parties are not acting as voices of the government. No reasonable person would even remotely think that the police turning their back on the mayor is 'what the government message is'. Those police are clearly not 'speaking' in an official government capacity (and literally are not speaking at all).

I have no great love for the police, but the correct path forward is a fair view, not a knee-jerk 'fire them all on principle'. This thread is full of knee-jerk hysteria, but the irony is that so many people are calling for an end to multiple people's careers because, while not on duty, the were literally standing still while facing the incorrect direction. Ironic because it's supposedly a reaction against undue application of power, and yet the punishment for facing the wrong way is termination, regardless of whether or not that officer has abused power elsewhere.

Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by agwa on Saturday May 02, 2015 @10:15PM (#9479503)
> In the first link, the case is about a memo written on duty as part of the employee's role; a uniform is irrelevant (and the word 'uniform' is mentioned zero times in the document).

The facts are not identical, but the facts are sufficiently similar that you could cite that case as precedence for arguing that the facts in question here should be treated similarly. The lawyer I linked to certainly thinks so. Are you a lawyer?

> In the second link, the article explicitly states: "Wearing a badge doesn’t forfeit the free speech of the person".

You took that out of context. "Person" here means the private person, not the cop representing himself as a cop. The paragraph goes on to say, "the speech of a person who presents himself in his official governmental capacity is no longer the individual’s free speech, but the official person’s speech. And the latter is not free."

Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by vacri on Saturday May 02, 2015 @10:50PM (#9479594)
Speaking of taking things out of context, did you read the rest of my paragraph, which talks about private speech versus official capacity, and matches the context surrounding my quote from the article?

in his official governmental capacity were the words - the funeral/protesting police were not on the clock on active duty, and as I said, no-one sane would confuse their message with a governmental message, official or unofficial.

Are you a lawyer?

?

It's clear neither of us are. So what? You're still misreading the second article re: private vs offical personage. That article is not saying what you're claiming it says. And as a result, the first link you provided is also not supporting your claims. The lawyer you linked to says absolutely nothing about uniforms - the term (and concept) 'uniform' appears nowhere in the article, but it does talk about the loss of freedom of speech when speaking in an official capacity.

And no, 'in uniform' is not the same as 'official capacity'. In none of these cases are they equivalent: the district attorney doesn't wear a uniform; Novara's phone call was about abusing his official capacity, and he could have been in the nude when he called, for all it mattered; the police turning their backs at the funeral are clearly not acting as a government voice and couldn't be confused to be doing so.

Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by mapt on Saturday May 02, 2015 @07:36PM (#9478995)
There are limits. You probably wouldn't object to a police officer being fired when it's discovered they have 5,000 posts on Stormfront expressing solidarity for their Aryan brothers in their struggle against multicultural impurity.

These police officers expressed contempt in an organized, planned way for anyone who would hold police officers accountable for murders committed on the job. They essentially declared that they expect 100% support from their boss in the executive branch, no matter the illegality of their conduct, and committed to staging a standing strike in protest, and to publicly shunning their boss at a funeral. It's a power play that a nation of rights & laws cannot permit, if it wants to remain one.

You know what? We can find other people to be police officers. Ones which aren't so abusive of the people they're supposed to be serving, and so privileged to a lack of consequences for this abuse, that they're on the edge of a coup against the elected civilian government.

Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by chrismcb on Monday May 04, 2015 @05:29AM (#9485129)
I most certainly would object to firing a police officer who had a ton if posts. As long as it didn't interfere with his duty as a police officer.
Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by Hobotron1 on Saturday May 02, 2015 @07:42PM (#9479014)
> We can find other people to be police officers.

Can we though? I sure as shit don't want to be one.

Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by Snesker on Saturday May 02, 2015 @08:26PM (#9479171)
They don't want you, you're probably too smart.

http://abcnews.go.com/US/court-oks-barring-high-iqs-cops/sto...

Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by simplexion on Sunday May 03, 2015 @03:05AM (#9480333)
Feels good to be too intelligent to be a Cop in the USA.
Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by HarryHirsch on Saturday May 02, 2015 @07:38PM (#9479005)
Are you serious? Members of the police force are prevented from to expressing their opinion while in uniform, they are sworn to duty. If they do it anyway, that way lie the Freikorps of the Weimar Republic. As the grandparent says, these guys need the equivalent of a dishonourable discharge.
Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by vacri on Saturday May 02, 2015 @09:38PM (#9479409)
Yes, a peaceful, static protest by simply facing the other way while uniformed but off the clock - at a funeral for a colleague - is totally the basis of a new Nazi state and the tens of millions of deaths it caused.
Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by kw71 on Saturday May 02, 2015 @07:41PM (#9479013)
What would you expect would happen to you if you made such a brazen, public display of disrespect against your executive management? Would you have your job after?

They certainly could have gone on strike, when they were not on the clock.

Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by mc32 on Saturday May 02, 2015 @07:52PM (#9479046)
They have strong unions. That allows them lots of things regular workers don't get. Unionized workers get these kinds of benefits --not that I agree with unions, as I think they are past their expiration date, but the strong ones provide great extra-work related benefits.

Similarly longshores get pretty sweet benefits too.

Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by spiritplumber on Sunday May 03, 2015 @02:18AM (#9480233)
Dock work is pretty backbreaking - I'm in favor of people who do that year round, rather than four weeks to make some extra cash for the summer one time like I did, getting good pensions and good health care. You only have one spine and it's gotta last you a lifetime.
Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by danieltillett on Sunday May 03, 2015 @07:23AM (#9480893)
It was 50 years ago - now it involves a lot of cranes and comfortable seats.
Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by spiritplumber on Sunday May 03, 2015 @08:35AM (#9481048)
It involves a couple of cranes and a lot of moving stuff that's too light to justify bringing the crane over but still seriously heavy, at least where I was (Italy).
Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by danieltillett on Sunday May 03, 2015 @06:23PM (#9483319)
I don’t think there is too much non-containerized goods coming in through the major US ports these days. Handling goods via small ports are still back-breaking work around the world though.
Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by privong on Saturday May 02, 2015 @07:33PM (#9478986)
Yes, they should be free to express their opinions. But free speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences. One could make a case that that sort of behavior could be considered insubordination and grounds for termination.
Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by agwa on Saturday May 02, 2015 @08:31PM (#9479194)
> Yes, they should be free to express their opinions. But free speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences.

That's bad analysis. Free speech means freedom from government-imposed consequences, and since their employer is the government, being fired would be a government-imposed consequence. (For the same reason, public universities cannot discipline students for their protected speech.) Rather, the correct reason these cops should be fired is because they legally do not have the right of free speech when in uniform - see my other comment up-thread.

Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by privong on Saturday May 02, 2015 @09:02PM (#9479294)
Fair enough, my analysis wasn't sufficiently specific. I agree that gov't employees should be free from government-imposed consequences if they are critizing policy. In contrast directly disregarding one's boss, while working in an official capacity, should not necessarily be free from government-imposed consequences (i.e., that should be a sanctionable offense). Obviously there's a divding line betwen the two, so it depends where that line is drawn (and where one places the actions of those officers on that spectrum).
Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by PhasmaFelis on Saturday May 02, 2015 @11:35PM (#9479725)
Try walking up to your boss and telling him he's a worthless fuckhead, then claim free speech when you get fired.

Free speech does not insulate you from reasonable consequences of that speech.

Re:What happens after you’re arrested at a protest in New York by woah on Saturday May 02, 2015 @10:49PM (#9479593)
Since when does the first amendment keep you from being fired when you publicly insult the ceo?