News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Evaluation of C, Go, and Rust in the HPC environment [pdf] by mrfloya on Saturday May 02, 2015 @05:25PM (#9478633)
Hey author of the thesis here.

You are correct this was definitely an oversight and I would have redone the measurements if time allowed for it. However I just want to state that the libaries were built with optimizations just not on the target platform which might not have been clear from the qoute.

Re:Evaluation of C, Go, and Rust in the HPC environment [pdf] by acadien on Sunday May 03, 2015 @01:49AM (#9480159)
Hey Floya, I'm writing this here hoping you'll see this comment. You're getting a lot of unjust responses in here. The commentors are reading your thesis with the eyes of a trained skeptic expecting peer reviewed, collaborative work that takes years of experience to produce. They're nitpicking flaws and mistakes we all make when we first start researching.

Your thesis is in fact really impressive and very nicely written! Your conclusions and future work section is excellent. Really very well done. Congratulations on finishing it. I hope you don't let the irrationally negative feedback here dissuade you from continuing your work, you certainly have a bright future ahead of you.

Re:Evaluation of C, Go, and Rust in the HPC environment [pdf] by angry_octet on Sunday May 03, 2015 @05:49AM (#9480668)
Hope the HN experience hasn't felt too bruising. The use of go and rust makes it quite interesting for those of us interested in correct code, not just fast code. And most of the criticism is that you didn't write the paper the commenter would have wanted to see, or didn't write a graduate level paper. And good on you for publishing it on github.