News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Pinball Ate itself: The Economics of Pinball by jerf on Wednesday November 18, 2009 @12:32AM (#947833)
Dynamic difficulty is a terrible idea. It reduces the potential difficulty-space of the game to two basic cases: Always too easy and always too hard. It means that if you lost, it's because the game chose to make you lose, not because of an effect on your choices, and if you win, it's because the game chose to let you win, not because of your skill.

Every couple of years I'll play a game with this new, innovative idea, and it's still the same story. It's sort of fun for a bit, until your brain catches up and realizes that as meaningless as most games are, this one is even more so. It's not a new idea and if it were going to work, it would have been made to work by now: http://www.intellivisiongames.com/bluesky/games/credits/spac...

(No, there is no in-between "just right". Simple control theory shows how you can't hover at the "just right" point; as you are at "just right", the system must dynamically adjust the difficulty above your level (or you even just hit a bad patch) and cause you to fail, at which point you're back at too easy. There's nowhere near enough data to get to "just right" even in theory.)

Re:How Pinball Ate itself: The Economics of Pinball by ubernostrum on Wednesday November 18, 2009 @02:05AM (#947931)
I haven't personally played it, but people I respect have been saying that the Left 4 Dead series is actually doing a good job of this.

(also, as a general rule I have an extreme distrust of "nobody I know of has managed this yet, therefore no-one anywhere ever will")

Re:How Pinball Ate itself: The Economics of Pinball by jerf on Wednesday November 18, 2009 @10:39AM (#948434)
And I have a pretty extreme distrust of "Yeah, I know thousands of smart people have tried and failed, but I'm still sure it's a great idea!" See also: General purpose visual programming, 3D desktop or chat interfaces (and I mean true 3D, not "using 3D hardware for nice effects), "I'll just wrap a natural language interface around this and it'll be easy to use!".

Certainly both of our rules fire off, but for every time your rule hits, mine hits several thousand times.