Re:How the language you speak changes your view of the world
by lordnacho on Saturday May 02, 2015 @02:02PM
(#9477923)
But what is causing the irregularity? Is there any benefit to conjugating "to be" differently to everything else?
Re:How the language you speak changes your view of the world
by cynicalkane on Sunday May 03, 2015 @12:01AM
(#9479825)
It's thought to be a combination of colloquialisms + the Indo-European ablaut system, wherein vowels would change depending on conjugation.
Consider how many English irregular verbs follow a pattern. Sing, sang, sung. Ring, rang, rung. These are ablaut conjugations.
Many European languages are not. Often with numbers between 11 and 99 are a weird special case. German puts the single digit first. As another poster mentioned 23 is "dreiundzwanzig" (literally "3 and 20"). French is worse where 97 is "quatre-vingts dix-sept" (literally "4 20s 10 7").
These are just the last remnants of a pre-decimal ("vigesimal" specifically) counting system.
I don't really see how weird rule exclusions on certain numbers would give anyone an advantage in math, particularly because even though the word means "4 20s" when you learn it, it's just a word and it may well just lead to questions like "why isn't 40 2 20s?" There is a cognitive cost with exclusions.
I remember reading a study once about how verbs became regular in English. There was a mathematical relationship between how often the word was used and how quickly it became regular. The less used, the quicker it happened.
This is why "to be" is irregular (as its the most common verb) whereas most other verbs (with <100 exclusions) follow a simple pattern.
It's probably the same with numbers. The numbers less than 100 are used far more often so their irregularity is preserved far longer than the less common numbers above 100.