Companies succeed by being in the right place at the right time, being lucky, having good connections, and having leaders who make the right decisions. If any of those is missing, failure is certain. If they're all present, failure is merely likely. As a rank and file employee, you can sometimes cause a very small company to fail but you can never make any company successful. You're just there to execute; execution is at least somewhat necessary but never anywhere near sufficient.
The idea that making my economic outcome dependent on so many factors over which I have no control whatever is not merely expedient or regrettably unavoidable but explicitly fair would be silly if it were not so abhorrent.
If an organization like Youtube/PickYourUnicorn sells for a billion plus dollars with only a small handful of employees, all of which are talented and have put in long hours, would it be fair for only the VCs and founders to see the upside?
In a sense I view equity as a shared call option.
If you still think there's a problem here, pay market wages and let anyone who chooses come along on their own dime on any subsequent funding round at fair value. No vesting/expiring options, no stock grants, no look-back, no discount, no limits, just the opportunity to be an investor -- in the moment -- on the same terms as everyone else. Just make sure (non-)participation is 100% confidential. I think very few of your employees genuinely want to be capitalists, but those who do should have to put cash on the barrelhead like everyone else.
There are downsides (lack of control of share price, and some freeloading) but for startups it's a great tool. The effectiveness shrinks a bit for large firms.