News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What's wrong with finance by PaulHoule on Saturday May 02, 2015 @10:51AM (#9477268)
Lotsa issues.

If financing (of some kind or another) is available for housing, education or health care, prices go up. In the case of housing nobody saw this as a problem: the house my parents built appreciated 10x before we sold it, and even people who were stuck buying a postage stamp sized house in California for $1M believed they were going to sell it for $5M.

At some point you have to starve the beast, that's the one thing that works.

It is astonishing how much capital is kicking around doing nothing. There is this continuous drumbeat that we can't upgrade rural America to optic fiber for instance, although Apple has the cash to do it and surely it has to be a better investment than negative interest rate bonds.

There are lots of reason why it doesn't happen and it is not that "fiber is too expensive", rather it is that Frontier can make $135 a month already selling me two phone lines and two 1.2 Mbps DSL connections and that Apple has cozy relations with wireless carriers who wouldn't want any competition for their $10 a GB money party.

Re:What's wrong with finance by seanmcdirmid on Saturday May 02, 2015 @11:06AM (#9477330)
Fiber to non-dense rural locations would almost certainly cost more than you are willing to pay, which is part of the reason you pay that much for the little you are getting now (the other being a lack of competition since the market is too small to support much diversity). There are plenty of bridges to nowhere that we can apply capital too, but they won't be good investments.
Re:What's wrong with finance by PaulHoule on Saturday May 02, 2015 @12:12PM (#9477536)
If we'd had that attitude 80 years ago there would be no electricity or phone service in rural areas.

So far as the cost, when you consider the effect on property values, income and stuff, the eye-popping numbers for what it costs to wire a house really are not that much, particularly when you realize services can be offered over them for 50+ years.

Often those eye-popping numbers are offered as a bluff by providers who don't want to serve an area. If you work in the IT field, $20,000 to get cable at your house pays itself back and you can put it on your HELOC if you don't have it an cash.

The problem here is not just a lack of competition but it is the competition for capital against bling-bling LTE phones and harvesting old copper wires and other things that make money quicker.

It is generally the case that government redistributes money from urban areas to rural, largely because rural areas subsidize urban areas in other ways. For instance, Silicon Valley would not have the stream of young labor that it has if there weren't places where people could afford to raise children.

Re:What's wrong with finance by seanmcdirmid on Saturday May 02, 2015 @04:45PM (#9478498)
We setup public subsidies and forced providers to serve unprofitable rural areas so they could serve more profitable urban ones. This is as it should be: it doesn't make sense for private industry to serve these people directly. So the government steps in for the public good, the rural areas do provide food after all.

Wireless should actually be the future for less dense rural areas, something like Google balooon anyways. How else can we even think of serving the Alaskan outback? Heck, I have family who just live an hour north of Spokane WA, and there best option up until a few years ago was satellite.

Re:What's wrong with finance by digi_owl on Saturday May 02, 2015 @12:40PM (#9477624)
One wonder if telecom should be handled like roads. Have one set of cables/fibers put in place by a government entity and then rent it out to all comers that want to deliver a service over it.
Re:What's wrong with finance by PaulHoule on Saturday May 02, 2015 @12:48PM (#9477659)
That's the best idea. There would be none of these interconnection problems if you could switch your middle mile provider if they wren't providing good service to Netflix.
Re:What's wrong with finance by seanmcdirmid on Saturday May 02, 2015 @04:47PM (#9478504)
Ironically, rural voters tend to be more conservative and increasingly libertarian, so they will never ask for this.
Re:What's wrong with finance by PaulHoule on Saturday May 02, 2015 @09:16PM (#9479333)
Oddly, they will vote for candidates who will push for fiber at the municipal level, but once you get involved with the Republican machine at the state level it is about bending over for Frontier.
Re:What's wrong with finance by prostoalex on Saturday May 02, 2015 @09:18PM (#9479338)
> If financing (of some kind or another) is available for housing, education or health care, prices go up.

But if there's no financing for housing, builders are realistic about their chances of selling something that's that expensive, stop building, and prices go up due to the lack of supply.

Re:What's wrong with finance by pas on Saturday May 02, 2015 @10:29PM (#9479538)
Yes, of course. The technical way is to say that financing pushes the equilibrium price upward. (Because it's just pure inflation, since it's new money created by the bank, and now people have more money to buy houses. The housing market then of course tries to correct, so the price goes up.) What you wrote is a hypothetical overcorrection when financing suddenly stops, the price crashes. (Sound familiar?) And then the supply of new houses reacts eventually, which then sets a new equilibrium.