Up until the keyword association, you were in a moderately defensible position. But deceit, materialism and shallow -- associating those sensations with what some people wear is some regrettable kind of -ism. How do you feel, in a group of engineers, if someone choose to not wear Dr Martens (or something comparably expensive)? If a collared shirt is worn, something casual and comfortable say, have they also abandoned everything you think they should hold dear about being an engineer?
I do judge people by their work, especially me, and ultimately would never let just the shell tell a person's story :-)
There's a wide range of choices between wearing clothes that are well suited to what you'll physically be doing in them, and wearing clothes suited to signaling something about yourself, and where clothing falls in that range does say something about the wearer.
[1] by silhouette, I mean the shaping of the figure via structuring of the garment.
Full disclosure: I originally trained in tailoring before becoming a developer
Why apologize? One of my favorite former colleagues ever was a PM. I loved working for/with him. When he was around, he was a bit like having a personal concierge/bouncer. If anyone else in the company bothered someone who was working on one of his projects, he'd chase them away, post haste; most of the time nobody ever even got close. He wore sneakers, crappy cargo pants, and tshirts. HR hated him. He could be a bit stubborn about technical decisions when he thought they were within his area of competence, but he was a knowledgeable guy. When he wasn't needed, he left the engineers alone. Anyway, I was happy to work with this guy and I never felt like he was "above me" even though he certainly was in terms of pay.
PS I like old Mercedes diesels, when you see one, don't be angry, that car is helping to bridge the economic divide. No, really, they are dirt cheap cars, and pretty well built.
Well, according to OP they are subject to a prisoner's dilemma and have chosen "defect" which is definitely a form of subjugation, albeit in the sense of fashion rather than economics. On this basis alone I think a certain amount of "anti-suit" culture is probably healthy, regardless of whether one believes that rebellion is just another kind of conformity or whether one believes that the economic implications mirror the fashion implications.
> When I see suits, I think of keywords like "deceit" and "materialism" and "shallow".
I tend to agree, but I think most people take an amoral approach: they look at the suit and the positive impression of "power" outweighs the negative impression of "what power does" or "how power is obtained."
When I see suits, I think of keywords like "deceit" and "materialism" and "shallow". I also feel like people in suits are being subjugated, no matter how high up the totem pole they think they are. I grew up painfully poor, so I assume much of my opinion and reaction to seeing a suit comes from feeling the vast economic divide between me and people in suits, much the way I feel a sickness and anger when I see people in cars like Mercedes, BMW and Jaguar.
Suits make people think differently. But for the right reasons? I will never "suit up", personally, by choice.