They weren't taking outsized risks in order to chase an outsized gain - "chasing returns" as you put it.
2008 changed all that.
Once government debt yields dropped to zero (done to save the bankers' hides), in order to still maintain the same returns which they needed, they started chasing returns.
This was more done out of desperation than greed. They had made promises pre-crisis that presumed the economy would continue as normal - exactly what economists and bankers of the time promised us would happen.
The only non pension funds who own anything substantial are governments. Private holdings are vanishingly small.
Who do you think owned the shares in the banks that took all the risks? 99% Pension Funds. Even if the Pension Funds had 85% as Government Bonds, from the rest they still owned 99% of the banks and hedge funds and private equity.
Holding bank shares is a suckers' game, however. Real money is made in bonuses:
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/study-bank-bonuses-far-exceeded-...
Control is more important than holding a share certificate entitling you to a residual claim on profits.
The sub funds that Pensions invest in get rewarded according to Alpha... the amount the sub fund exceeded the main stock price movement.
How is that not chasing returns??
http://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/alpha.asp