The rational conclusion from this is that mainstream academic theory - i.e. not people like Keen - is a source of collective stupidity.
See e.g.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/finance/economics/8089832/We-cant...
When untrained people can predict the future more accurately than trained experts, the training of those experts has negative social value.
This in contrast to mainstream people who talk about economics, who have been predicting hyperinflation for years now.
There were many academics who warned that austerity policies would be a drag on the economy for years. There were people in academics warning about a possible housing bubble.
Excerpt From: Anonymous Hedge Fund Manager, n+1and Keith Gessen. “Diary of a Very Bad Year.” HarperCollins, 2010.
Sometimes they are right.
The aftermath of the financial crisis seems to have been handled remarkably well though, don't you think? At least in the US the economy is doing fairly well and the deleveraging was handled admirably.
Unfortunately, that ignores: - the labor participation rate is dropping steadily.. because long term unemployment is up. - the Fed has pumped $1T (yes, trillion) into the market each of the last 5 (6?) years. - wages have been stagnant and have only now reached 1998 levels. - education - previously a ticket into the middle class and beyond - has been devalued by poor standards but simultaneously the price tag has increased dramatically.
And that means -- if I might be prophetic for a moment -- that it's all going to happen again.
Hell no. It was used as an excuse to shovel money into the pockets of the ultrawealthy.
>At least in the US the economy is doing fairly well
By what measure?
Because if you're going to count employment, you should factor out the people who used to have decent middle class jobs and are now scraping by working at walmart.
This is rather an understatement. Most neoclassical models (the dominant strain of economics, despite its demonstrated failure to predict crises) basically assume that the financial sector doesn't exist.
This is why most economists' reaction was "nobody could see it coming" and their policy recommendation response to the crisis was "even more of the same, please" (deregulation, desupervision and de-facto decriminalization).
Then they wonder why people don't respect them any more.
"Hope", as such, does not come from the school of behavioral economics. That was getting trendy even before the crisis hit and did not help at all. Personally, I can think of only one economist who is making models that accurately model the behavior of financial institutions in the macro-economy - Steve Keen, who is resurrecting and extending upon Hyman Minsky's instability hypothesis.