I don't have access to the Mondo 2000 stuff today, but if any of that was to believed we'd have AI masterminded rockets to moon condos and eternal life by now. The big advances were actually missed as things like interchangable and standardized protocols, power saving SoCs, incremental battery improvements, touchscreens, and fast networks are "boring" compared to spacetravel and robots and such.
I feel I'm also seeing the same hype train today with VR, which has unsolved major issues like motion sickness and questionable applications in gaming, let alone anywhere else. To a lesser extent I see the same thing with electric cars that are always somehow 2-3 years from affordability and economic and range parity with ICE cars. These 2-3 years keep blowing past us, but there's no 200 mile range $20,000 car yet, if there will ever be.
Its a shame that practical and real advances are often "boring" to the typical sci-fi obsessed INTJ males who dominate science on the internet. I see so much spilled ink about SpaceX and very little about the upcoming SLS and its planned pioneering manned missions or NASA's robotic and science missions, which are all mindblowingly amazing to me. Sadly, this has all become politicized in the most asinine way possible with a dedicated libertarian group on the web voicing this private vs public rivalry to attack NASA, which is ironic as SpaceX is more or less a welfare program of NASA and the US taxpayers.
I hope this fad doesn't last long and good science, real breakthroughs, and the largely unpredictable and usually unsexy, in terms of whiz bang space operas, future continues to unfold before us in a wonderful way. The SLS will have us on an asteroid with just boring old chemical rockets, while the futurists continue to sell snake oil to the low information true believers and diminish the amazing and real accomplishments of the day.
"Everything's amazing and nobody's happy." - Louis CK.
eh-hem implying the Myers-Briggs Personality Type is based on rigorous science /sardony /irony.
BTW the reason SpaceX is more exciting than SLS is VTVL reusability.
I think this phrase sums it the best
I also usually remember that the Casimir effect, a tested and true effect, used to take a lab of experts some years to reproduce results
Heliocentric solar system.
Circulation of blood in the body.
Yes they're "a long time ago" (really, a few centuries isn't a long time), but they're the tip of the iceberg of contested knowledge.
Also the roundness of the earth was never as far as I know controversial among the learned. Heliocentricity was only controversial for religious reasons.
[1] http://www.wired.co.uk/news/archive/2013-02/06/emdrive-and-c...
You can't show something as simple as aspirine 'works' by setting up a lab experiment without test subjects. And as soon as you involve those, it becomes legally complex, expensive, time consuming and hard.
You simply can't compare medical experiments to physics experiments. A physics experiment can be set up to be extremely controlled. If you observe some effect, the number of things it could be due to is very small.
A medical experiment requires people with all their messiness and possibly confounding variables. If you observe some effect, there are zounds of possible explanations. Controlling for all of them requires many test subjects. That makes it expensive, time consuming and hard.
Even a medical experiment on human cells in a petri dish is infinitely more complex than a physics experiment, in terms of variables involved.
Homeopathy doesn't claim that "some substance heals people". It claims (according to Wikipedia [1]) "a substance that causes the symptoms of a disease in healthy people will cure similar symptoms in sick people".
It's fundamentally flawed, and despite revisionist practitioners, has not yet managed to raise it's head above "pseudoscience" status.
It shouldn't really be mentioned in the same sentence as research that is actually trying to determine if a substance has an effect, even if that research is flawed. Said research and homeopathy aren't really playing on the same field. It's like calling religion a science. It's based on a premise that can't be questioned without throwing out the entire idea.
This seems to be about "reaction-less drives" - I remember reading about how hard-headed SF editor J.W.Campbell had a weak spot for such devices, several decades ago. He entertained a few demos, if memory serves.
Didn't pan out then, probably won't now.
During the "Cold Fusion" era, when Pons & Fleishman had claimed to develop room temperature fusion, I worked for a major US lab doing superconductor research. (We invented the first superconductors that operated at liquid nitrogen temperatures-- Y1B2C3O)
While fusion isn't our area of investigation we, being physicists, were curious. We managed to get our hands on a pre-print of the Pons & Fleishman study and did our own experiments.
We kept this very hush hush. We didn't want it getting out that we were doing the experiments or people would claim that we replicated them.
So, I believe that SpaceX and other companies are experimenting with this, and if they found good results (as the eagle works tests imply they would) they would continue to do so, but in secret.)
We eventually published our paper because we constructed a novel experiment that disproved the P&F observation, from our perspective.
None-the-less, true to our fears, this was later reported by "Mondo 2000" (The "arse technica" crossed with WIRED of the day) that we had "confirmed cold fusion is real!!1!1". The letter to the editor I wrote and got our most eminent physicist to sign was never printed by the magazine (IIRC).
When you get to the fringes-- that's where the action is-- but it's also where you can have confusing or odd results.
And even 30 years ago the media was not trustworthy enough to reveal these results to. Our paper was published in a journal, and yet the media still mis represented the results.