Re:Shameful Innumeracy in the New York Times
by ryanwaggoner on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @02:57PM
(#947114)
I actually kind of enjoyed watching this guy spin himself into a frenzy and conclude that the NYT editors have no basic understanding of anything, based solely on what could have easily just been a typo. Some people really have too much time on their hands.
Re:Shameful Innumeracy in the New York Times
by steveitis on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @03:13PM
(#947145)
You posted a comment about your enjoyment of the authors failure, and judged his time management skills due to the fact that he posted his rant about another persons failure on the internet.
Re:Shameful Innumeracy in the New York Times
by gloob on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @07:56PM
(#947554)
The commenter you responded to wasn't being amused by the author's time management skills (or lack thereof). He was amused by the author's emotional state.
Re:Shameful Innumeracy in the New York Times
by camccann on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @07:15PM
(#947513)
Sure, it could have been a typo, or some other minor mistake.
But he's also correct that it's hilariously wrong. Is it really asking too much that something published in the New York Times either have sufficient editing and proofreading to not make an embarrassing typo, or refrain from using terms they don't understand the meaning of, whichever the case may be?
Even if it's only an editorial, it undermines confidence in the paper as a whole. How often do they make similarly silly mistakes on things where I don't know better?
Re:Shameful Innumeracy in the New York Times
by Eliezer on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @08:05PM
(#947566)
As a teenager, I had an almost exactly similar conversation to this with a line editor of the GED (after looking at a "sample question" on the official GED website). I exchanged a couple of emails and I'm pretty sure she flatly did not understand the concept of a percentile.
Yes, I'm sure that she was the problem and not me. I ran it past my father, a Ph.D. physicist, and he couldn't figure out how to attach a sane interpretation to her remarks either.
Re:Shameful Innumeracy in the New York Times
by camccann on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @09:11PM
(#947648)
Speaking from personal experience, understanding the concept of much of anything is, alas, not really required to pass the GED. So I fear that anyone who can comprehend an advanced concept such as "percentiles" would be wasting their talents on anything involving the GED.
Re:Shameful Innumeracy in the New York Times
by FreeRadical on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @03:02PM
(#947121)
comment #6 on the blog said
"Some well established federal organizations (ie, NIH) do percentiles backwards. That is, 85 percentile score better than 15%. Maybe that's what's going on...."
Re:Shameful Innumeracy in the New York Times
by jacobolus on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @05:41PM
(#947390)
I’d really like to see a better explanation of that, or some evidence. It’s possible to order things from “best” to “worst”, with the bottom one percent being the best, but there’s really no way to interpret “below the 85th percentile” as anything other than “among the bottom 85%” without some special, personal, opposites-day definition of “percentile”.
Re:Shameful Innumeracy in the New York Times
by camccann on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @07:35PM
(#947535)
Reality check: The median regular poster on HN is probably in the 95th percentile or better for intelligence, knowledge, and general cluefulness. Hell, the median poster on slashdot is probably well above average.
The bloggers on ScienceBlogs are, in general, competent, intelligent, and well-educated. A faux-folksy disdain for competence plays well for the masses, but politically correct or not there is such thing as actual expertise and I don't know why you're insulting someone for pointing out that a large majority of people are completely unequipped to discuss anything involving even very basic statistics (or any other practical math).
Re:Shameful Innumeracy in the New York Times
by newsio on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @05:18PM
(#947354)
The author is the same person who wrote the much-commented scienceblogs post about why he won't go to his high school reunion. The post and the comments are well worth reading, if you haven't seen them before:
Re:Shameful Innumeracy in the New York Times
by Evgeny on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @05:02PM
(#947327)
So we could spend all the money and happily report that as a result of huge investments in education half of all low-income students now have above average test scores - a great improvement indeed!
Do you not see the hypocrisy?
So, no, they aren't being hypocritical about it.
If we keep going like this, we'll meta ourselves up a black hole or something.
But he's also correct that it's hilariously wrong. Is it really asking too much that something published in the New York Times either have sufficient editing and proofreading to not make an embarrassing typo, or refrain from using terms they don't understand the meaning of, whichever the case may be?
Even if it's only an editorial, it undermines confidence in the paper as a whole. How often do they make similarly silly mistakes on things where I don't know better?
http://www.amazon.com/dp/038548254X/
Yes, I'm sure that she was the problem and not me. I ran it past my father, a Ph.D. physicist, and he couldn't figure out how to attach a sane interpretation to her remarks either.
"Some well established federal organizations (ie, NIH) do percentiles backwards. That is, 85 percentile score better than 15%. Maybe that's what's going on...."
To show that at least some at the NIH have a perfectly reasonable understanding of percentiles, here’s a chart of boy’s blood pressure by height percentile: http://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/guidelines/hypertension/child_tbl.p...
The NIH’s percentile scoring system for grant applications certainly knows the proper meaning of “percentile”: http://www.med.nyu.edu/spa/education/PaylinesDescription.htm...
My guess is that the commenter was mistaken.
Gawrsh, I'm shore glad we have these here science bloggers to help drag us clueless folks out of the mud.
The bloggers on ScienceBlogs are, in general, competent, intelligent, and well-educated. A faux-folksy disdain for competence plays well for the masses, but politically correct or not there is such thing as actual expertise and I don't know why you're insulting someone for pointing out that a large majority of people are completely unequipped to discuss anything involving even very basic statistics (or any other practical math).
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=709733
Consider: 99% of Americans own a below-average number of houseboats.
Clearly there must be no correlation between income and intelligence!