You just said a mouthful :-)
When I started making my own wine a friend sent me a review of a Barolo -- the variety I was making -- and I mentioned that the wine review seemed awfully similar to high end audio equipment reviews (e.g., $15k CD transports + another $10k for the DAC and preamp!) and sent him a few links.
He was absolutely astounded (and amused): both kinds of reviews used language so similar that in some cases they were almost interchangeable.
What's my point? Both products can be very expensive with little objective differentiation leaving the buyer with a great deal of incentive to defend his purchase vigorously to anyone who asks the question, "why the hell did you spend so much money on that"
Both products can be very expensive with little objective differentiation leaving the buyer with a great deal of incentive to defend his purchase vigorously to anyone who asks the question, "why the hell did you spend so much money on that"
To which the appropriate reply is: "I didn't spend my money on that, I spent my money on me (or you, or our dinner, or your graduation, etc)
It's like weighing the steak at a fancy restaurant and comparing it to the price-per-pound down at Costco
It reminds me of my step-father's view on haircuts: for a certain amount of money, you deserve to get at least so much hair removed. :)
Having said that, I've got a bottle of 98 Donnoff Riesling that has my name on it for Christmas Eve. And I've been saving a 1996 Opus One for gosh, I don't know, perhaps the end of the world or my first million :) And I'm thinking that I've sat on those 4 bottles of 97 Dow's Port long enough.
To my mind, I'll take these wines and statistically match them up anywhere. But who cares if I'm wrong and it's just me? I've enjoyed collecting them, and I'll enjoy the special feeling of consuming them when I think the time is right.
But damn it, I'm right. (grin)
Wine is an immensely subjective and varied experience. That's one of the reasons people like it so much. There's one feeling you get when you're dining out and a friend turns you on to a 10-dollar red that tastes great and another feeling you get when you go to the cellar for a special occasion to get a hundred-dollar bottle -- even if the wines are statistically indistinguishable.
What can I say? It's a great product. All of human experience goes into the process: peer pressure, prior experience, atmosphere, cost, anticipated pleasure, etc.
When I started trying to learn how to taste wine I went through Wine Spectator and only ordered wines of the very highest rating. I understand this is just an anecdote, but I found that about 1 in 3 were actually distinguishable by me from grocery-store wine. I took that to mean that yes, there are differences, but the amount of signal is vastly overstated.
But that misses the point: it's emotional, not statistical.