News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Wine Ratings Are Badly Flawed by dockd on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @01:05PM (#946871)
I think a better comparison is to have a wide range of prices for a single varietal. For example, a white is going to taste different than a red. Does one of them taste better?

High-end reds cost more than high-end whites. That could be because they do taste better, are more costly to produce or are more rare.

That said, thumb through a Wine Spectator and you'll see a bunch of high-priced wines that don't rate as well as their price suggests. I usually have good luck with buying bottles where the wine steward has added a special "yummy" sticker or writeup.

Maybe another fun game would be to bring in a favorite art object and have everyone guess what it cost. Just because you or I wouldn't pay $100 for a Kinkade doesn't mean that a lot of people will.

Perhaps this is the sort of thing that happens when we make judgments in areas where we lack expertise.

Re:Why Wine Ratings Are Badly Flawed by silentbicycle on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @04:41PM (#947272)
If I'm not mistaken, part of it is that reds age better (due to the tannins).