News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Wine Ratings Are Badly Flawed by rdtsc on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @10:45AM (#946592)
I am convinced that many wineries should sell the same wine for different prices. They could sell the same wine for $7/bottle, $30/bottle and $125/bottle. Of course the $125 should have a different label and should be marketed a lot differently but the wine itself doesn't have to change.

I personally just buy a big jug of dark red cooking wine. I can't tell the difference between it and the other more expensive wine, and I refuse to spend more money for snoberry (note: I have nothing against others paying that much if it makes them feel good/better).

Re:Why Wine Ratings Are Badly Flawed by carbon8 on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @01:06PM (#946873)
Well, there's a big difference between the issue of wine rating silliness and the wide variety of flavor you'll find in wine. A $10 bottle of gabbiano tastes almost nothing like a $10 bottle of monticello rioja and neither will taste anything like your jug of wine. Saying they taste the same is like to saying orange juice tastes the same as lemon juice, and that both taste the same as grapefruit juice.
Re:Why Wine Ratings Are Badly Flawed by rdtsc on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @02:30PM (#947064)
I was saying that I couldn't taste the difference and according to the article, many other people can't either. They are essentially tasting the label and the marketing, which is why the marketing and the label should look different in both cases.

They are people more sophisticated and better at wine tasting, but there are a lot of people who just follow irrational marketing cues.

Re:Why Wine Ratings Are Badly Flawed by carbon8 on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @03:31PM (#947175)
"I was saying that I couldn't taste the difference and according to the article, many other people can't either."

This isn't what the article is talking about. The article is arguing that subjective, linear wine ranking is faulty, that preferences are not objective or static, that it's difficult to distinguish between similar wines and that identifying individual flavors and scents (eg, "lavender, roasted herbs") are tied to the taster's imagination.

If you can tell the difference between grapefruit juice and orange juice, you can tell the difference between a gabbiano, a monticello rioja and a generic merlot. They taste dramatically different and you can't give a merlot to someone who knows what chianti tastes like and have them believe it's a chianti. Different varietals have very distinct flavors.

And when it comes to quality, there is a much, much more significant difference between a poorly stored, very low-quality wine and a mainstream ~$10/bottle wine than there is between a $20/bottle wine and a $100/bottle wine. After all, a number of the pricer wines would be simply $20/bottle if it weren't for the ratings systems critiqued by the article.

Re:Why Wine Ratings Are Badly Flawed by ibsulon on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @01:08PM (#946876)
You don't taste any oxidation after a few days?

I'd suggest going with boxed wines if that's your preference. Target makes a really good one, and it stays good longer.

Re:Why Wine Ratings Are Badly Flawed by rdtsc on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @02:38PM (#947080)
Yes the boxed wine tastes better. I also keep it in the refrigerator and take some out some time before drinking it and let it sit. I think that's called "decantering" but I din't know when I started doing it, it just made the wine taste better.