News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Results of yesterday's personality poll: we're strange. by tc on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @07:43AM (#946311)
Does seeing the results affect your belief?

If you take as a given that the HN population is not representative of the population at large, then it is clear that Myers-Briggs measures something, as it correctly identified that.

If you'd asked me for a hypothesis before the survey, I would have predicted a significant overrepresentation of NT-types. That would seem to give the test some predictive value, unless you attribute the full significance of the findings to selection bias in who chose to answer (in which case Myers-Briggs would be an outstanding predictor of who will answer surveys).

Re:Results of yesterday's personality poll: we're strange. by Retric on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @08:18AM (#946356)
It's limited to sixteen personality types and most have trouble picking just one so I think it's fairly useless.

I can be extremely charming, I like being outgoing in large groups, and a friend of mine said I was probably the most popular person in high school. I also dislike most people so I spend a lot of time online. I can be extremely rational and I have little problems programming computers, but I often make irrational decisions on a whim because I trust my subconscious way to much.

So, I don't know am I an introvert or an extrovert, rational or irrational? I honestly don't know and I don't think picking one is important because they don't tell me something I don't already know.

Re:Results of yesterday's personality poll: we're strange. by niels on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @09:02AM (#946408)
OK, I may have overstated my opinion on this. You can probably say something about people using Myers-Briggs. However I feel weird beeing categorized like that. I am beeing typed as an introvert but I don't see myself as beeing introverted at all. This stuff is too vague and subjective for me to have any meaning (I guess you are gonna type me based on this??).