News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How GrubHub.com confirms with restaurants that they place... by mseebach on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @05:26AM (#946216)
> I don't think it would be so bad to say something like, "Your order is in our system. We'll confirm that the restaurant got it correctly and email you in a couple minutes."

It adds complexity but provides no value.

If you call a cab, you also accept "be there in 10 minutes", even though it's not confirmed, not "Right, tell you what, I'm gonna push this button on my radio, which closes an electrical curcuit connected to a big radio, and announce your request to our fleet of cars. Now, provided that there's no interference, and that the nearest car isn't in a garage or a tunnel or something, and if the driver isn't fighting with his wife on his cellphone, or in a place getting a coffee, he'll hear the message, and radio back confirmation. He'll then drive to your address, where, bar mechanical failure of perhaps the brakes or the pressurized oil system, he will arrive in 10 minutes. Have a good day."

> I think the most amusing part of this whole thing is that there's no way any user actually believes there are ~100 discrete steps to the order placement process, despite the high "progress resolution" of the progress bar.

Progress is often temporal, and time has infinite resolution. There may no be 4*60 distinct steps to the process of steeping a cup of tea, but we still accept the turn of the second-hand as a measure of progress.

Re:How GrubHub.com confirms with restaurants that they place... by endtime on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @02:18PM (#947023)
>If you call a cab, you also accept "be there in 10 minutes", even though it's not confirmed, not "Right, tell you what, I'm gonna push this button on my radio, which closes an electrical curcuit connected to a big radio, and announce your request to our fleet of cars. Now, provided that there's no interference, and that the nearest car isn't in a garage or a tunnel or something, and if the driver isn't fighting with his wife on his cellphone, or in a place getting a coffee, he'll hear the message, and radio back confirmation. He'll then drive to your address, where, bar mechanical failure of perhaps the brakes or the pressurized oil system, he will arrive in 10 minutes. Have a good day."

That's not really a fair comparison to "We'll confirm that the restaurant got your order and email you".

Re:How GrubHub.com confirms with restaurants that they place... by jrockway on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @02:36PM (#947076)
How long are you supposed to wait for the email? Why not just call the restaurant and cut the email-sending middleman out of the loop? It costs the same and takes less of your time.
Re:How GrubHub.com confirms with restaurants that they place... by endtime on Wednesday November 18, 2009 @06:06PM (#949358)
It doesn't take less of my time, because I can do other things while I wait for the confirmation. In fact, inducing me to sit and stare at a fake progress bar probably takes more of my time. And in any case, it saves me having to repeat my order to someone who doesn't speak great English, etc.
Re:How GrubHub.com confirms with restaurants that they place... by mseebach on Tuesday November 17, 2009 @03:10PM (#947139)
No, it's not, I was going for a bit of satire, I'm sorry.

"If you call a cab, you also accept "be there in 10 minutes", even though it's not confirmed" is, however, a fair comparison, IMHO.

Re:How GrubHub.com confirms with restaurants that they place... by endtime on Wednesday November 18, 2009 @06:05PM (#949355)
Heh, maybe I'm neurotic, but I actually hate it when they do that. I'd much rather they tell me something like "We can probably get you a car in about ten minutes, and we'll call to confirm or update that in two," if it were more reliable.