>every hipster made their own decision about how to handle congestion control
Unless they had access to a tier 1/2 network provider it'd be mostly harmless I suspect. They'd spam their local gateway. "Look I can send 300k packets a second over standard DSL"
But yes, TCP is generally a good thing.
In addition to reliability, TCP provides congestion control which provides approximate fairness of bandwidth utilization per connection. Fairness here meaning given a limited pipe of size W each connection gets a W/N slice of the pipe's available bandwidth. I don't know that I'd like to live on an internet where every hipster made their own decision about how to handle congestion control, see also congestive collapse.