Re:Scientists achieve critical steps to building first pract...
by Animats on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:09PM
(#9460389)
This is a very strange field. D-Wave is shipping quantum computers designed to do optimization problems, and yet nobody is really sure if they work.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Scientists achieve critical steps to building first pract...
by marcosdumay on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:39PM
(#9460668)
The D-Wave is not a quantum computer by the usual meaning of that term.
It's only a "quantum computer" by a definition created by their market department. A definition that also classifies as "quantum computer" the one you have on your desk.
Re:Scientists achieve critical steps to building first pract...
by jdjdps on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @03:15PM
(#9460951)
That's not entirely fair. D wave is attempting to use quantum effects anneal to solutions faster than a classical computer would. It's not what we would usually think of as a quantum computer, but its in the right ball park. No?
Re:Scientists achieve critical steps to building first pract...
by marcosdumay on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @10:29PM
(#9463004)
Well my desktop also uses quantum effects. So did valve computers at the time, thus, I don't think anybody ever built a "classical computer".
Yes, that's the definition they use on their site. No, I don't think applying it verbatim to my computer is unfair.
Ok, they created a different kind of classical computer. One that may be able to solve some kinds of problems better, like a specialized computer often does. Yes, it could have been huge (but wasn't - too bad). But it's not a quantum computer, and their marketing is dishonest.
Re:Scientists achieve critical steps to building first pract...
by titanomachy on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @03:36PM
(#9461110)
They claim to make use of quantum effects -- in an abstract sense, quantum tunnelling across potential peaks in the solution space to access classically unreachable absolute minima. If that claim is true, then I agree that D-Wave is a type of quantum computer. What is disputed, I believe, is the truth of the claim.
Re:Scientists achieve critical steps to building first pract...
by Tloewald on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @02:12PM
(#9460421)
It would seem phys.org is tacitly stating its opinion on the subject with the article title.
Re:Scientists achieve critical steps to building first pract...
by titanomachy on Wednesday April 29, 2015 @03:30PM
(#9461070)
"first practical quantum computer." They could just be referring to the fact that D-wave is impractical.