Re:Valve shuts down paid mod system after pressure from gamers
by madez on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @12:38PM
(#9453528)
Reasonableness usually implies more than just a logicality, including fairness. To then say that the 30% cut is reasonable means that to say that it's fair.
Let's assume reasonableness were equivalent to logicality. Then, for a decision to be reasonable, it must satisfy some logical conditions. I'd argue that is in our case maximizing a fixed metric in relation to all other possible options. One either doesn't value fairness in the decision-evaluation metric, the 30% cut is fair enough or it's unreasonable.
So, putting it all together, we get
(1) 30% is fair (enough),
(2) one doesn't value fairness prominently in decision making metrics or
(3) the 30% cut is unreasonable.
I'd say the 30% is _not_ fair (enough). That leaves one to pick (2) or (3).
- Fairness is a moral judgment.
- Reasonableness is a logical argument.
That's why I argued that Valve's taking 30% is reasonable but not necessarily fair.