Re:Ghostery and NoScript-like add-ons frequently phone home
by mook on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @10:53AM
(#9452769)
Getting updates published on the Firefox add-on site takes a few weeks [1], and as I understand it (haven't needed to do it myself recently) queuing a new version bumps you all the way to the back of the line. If the add-on needs to update non-code things (such as what sites to block) on a shorter time frame having its own service is pretty necessary.
See also the various lists adblock plus / uBlock / lightbeam use. Or for that matter the safe browsing lists Mozilla uses instead of shipping it in a new version of the app.
(I still don't use Ghostery because their relationship with the advertising industry freaks me out, but that doesn't mean I have to be critical of them about the list updates.)
[1] latest status update seems to be https://blog.mozilla.org/addons/2015/04/08/add-ons-update-63...
Re:Ghostery and NoScript-like add-ons frequently phone home
by talmand on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @09:36AM
(#9452203)
So, you are saying that every single extension in existence uses Mozilla's update feature and doesn't have an internal system for updating? Because it seems to me I've seen a few that seem to update themselves with no involvement of the add-on panel of Firefox.
Firefox is managing extension updates already. As an app developer, you don't need to know this data.
As a security surface, you really don't want this data in real-time. It makes you a target.
I presume the problem is that Firefox isn't sharing this install/update data with the extension developers. So, they're trying to collect it themselves.