Re:Ghostery and NoScript-like add-ons frequently phone home
by PhantomGremlin on Tuesday April 28, 2015 @01:36AM
(#9450655)
Did you know that dihydrogen monoxide was responsible for at least 368,000 deaths[1] worldwide in 2013? In the USA it's the second leading cause of death for children under 12 years old. Surely you'd want to know if a product had dihydrogen monoxide in it.
Misleading people is unethical. Providing incomplete information is misleading.
80% of Americans say they want labels on food warning if they contain DNA[0]. Not because people fear DNA, but because when you ask, that signals that DNA is potentially bad. Actually providing such a label is also a signal that DNA is bad.
Labeling food with "Warning: contains DNA" is unethical because it misleads people into thinking that's bad.
Adding a label saying "DNA-free" is unethical because it's false, unless you're selling salt. (And probably also misleading: https://xkcd.com/641/ )
But failing to provide such a label? Not misleading, and not unethical.
If someone asks "does X phone home, does Y contain DNA", you should answer honestly, but you should probably also provide explain the pros/cons. Granted, unless you planted the idea in their heads, that's not your responsibility, but if you publish an article saying "Food X contains DNA!" or "Plugin Y phones home!" you _are_ responsible for the resulting fear, and should qualify the information with an honest evaluation of what that means.
[0] http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2015...