Assuming that average here is an arithmetic mean (which is the most common use, but how are we quantifying "funniness" to warrant such a measure?), this would only be true if we assume a symmetric distribution with no individuals at the average.
This also assumes that objective funniness is even a meaningful concept; funniness is obviously subjective, and I would suspect that people tend to voluntarily socially engage with people that they find pleasant to be around -- part of which is having compatible sense of humor. So, the people you are voluntarily associating with (i.e., the people you are like to play CAH with) are likely to be disproportionately from the upper end of the funniness distribution from your subjective perspective -- and are likely to be among the upper end of the distribution in how they perceive your funniness, as well.
Your second point is a good one - clearly, funniness is subjective. On the other hand, I don't think my argument relies on the precise quantitative definition of funniness!
You cannot meaningfully add together how funny five people are and divide it by five. However, you can put five people in order of how funny they are, and point to the middle one.
The only appropriate concept of average for ordinal data (e.g. how funny someone is) is the median, from which it follows by definition that 50% of people are less funny than average.
PS - if it is true that it "cracks you up" every time you hear "the 50% of people are above/below average fallacy", I suggest that you might be one of the 50% of people who have a below-average sense of humour ;)
I would extrapolate further and say since there is a tiny number of comedians performing any night that there is both a non-even distribution of humor and that it is weighted towards fewer people having it. Consider, if it were so common, would the rest of us be as willing to pay to hear someone else perform?
And to be fair, I don't think that would be evidence in itself. I would be curious to see actual studies into this. At least a little.
Incorrect. For the four usual kinds of measures, the following types of "averages" are generally useful:
Nominal: Mode
Ordinal: Mode, Median
Interval: Mode, Median, Arithmetic Mean
Ratio: Mode, Median, All Means (arithmetic, geometric, harmonic)
> from which it follows by definition that 50% of people are less funny than average.
Nope, that only follows by definition for ordinal data with the additional assumption that no items have equal rank.
[0] consider that 50% of people are less funny than average, and then reflect on how funny the average person is.