News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Learning Advanced JavaScript by jacobolus on Monday November 16, 2009 @11:15AM (#944645)
> Turning an object into an array isn't a nice way to do things

This doesn’t happen. The object is unchanged when you call array.slice.

> Maybe runtimes optimize

Only insofar as the built-in array methods are optimized anyway.

> maybe they create completely new objects

No, they don’t. Or rather, yes, array.slice creates a new object to put the slice in, but only because that is part of its declared API.

> Yes it works well, but it's not really necessary.

What’s the alternative?

> It's inefficient wasted effort.

Inefficient how? If you time it, it’s faster other ways of accomplishing the same thing. Whose wasted effort? It certainly saves me time as a JavaScript developer.

* * *

To be honest, I think that arguments should just be an array (then we wouldn’t have any of this trouble), but I assume that’s not possible for the language at this point.

Re:Learning Advanced JavaScript by bumblebird on Monday November 16, 2009 @12:40PM (#944834)
>> This doesn’t happen. The object is unchanged when you call array.slice.

You're wrong. Why don't you check instead of reading API docs or saying what you think should happen? It obviously is changed, and is a new object: Array.prototype.slice.call({0:"hello",1:"world",foo:"bar",length:2});

Results in ["hello","world"] - the result is a completely new object - inefficient wasted effort. Both in cpu and memory.

Offtopic again, but here's an interesting way to make a new N element array, initialized with undefineds...

Array.prototype.slice.call({length:100}) = [undefined, undefined, undefined........ undefined]

Array.prototype.slice.call({length:10000000}) takes almost 1 second to run on my MBP while it's creating that new array.

>> What’s the alternative?

As I say, just write closures...

onclick = function(c){return function(){c.doSomething()}}(this);

It's not much more typing, and is more general. I agree arguments would be nicer if it was a true array though.

Re:Learning Advanced JavaScript by bumblebird on Monday November 16, 2009 @03:27PM (#945215)
Instead of downmodding, why not explain why you disagree with the facts I present above?