News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The art of butchery by stegosaurus on Sunday April 26, 2015 @08:10PM (#9443810)
The idea of a humane killing is nonsensical to me, really.

Imagine a thought experiment in which you could either die painlessly, or live but be required to endure days or weeks of incredibly painful torture (for the purposes of the experiment let's say that it doesn't leave lasting physical/emotional damage).

I'd pick the torture. I assume most other people would too.

I think that should illustrate fairly well that the distinction between life and death is so much greater than that between joy and suffering.

Re:The art of butchery by Falling3 on Sunday April 26, 2015 @09:38PM (#9444018)
I really doubt you or most other people can imagine what weeks of torture with death inevitably looming actually feels like. I think almost anyone would choose dying painlessly.
Re:The art of butchery by moogleii on Sunday April 26, 2015 @09:28PM (#9443988)
I'd probably pick the torture, too, but I think proponents of humane killing are comparing it with inhumane killing, so it's more like, would you rather choose to die painlessly, or endure weeks of incredibly painful torture before being killed. I'd probably choose the former in that case.
Re:The art of butchery by crpatino on Sunday April 26, 2015 @11:29PM (#9444259)
You are not making a fair comparison.

The (somewhat simplified) options available are: 1. Raise and slaughter animals in the most convenient and/or economically efficient way without regards for their suffering. (standard meat way) 2. Raise and slaughter animals in the most humane and painless way without regard for economic cost. (omnivore's dilemma way) 3. Do not raise any animals. Eat a 100% plan based diet. (vegan way).

There is no scenario where animals can trade enduring pain for anything. We are talking about domestic animals. They are born because we facilitated it, with the expectation of a gain from such activity.

I can see why people would want to be vegan, and while I do not share those opinions I respect them. But, if everybody thought like that, most domestic animal species would go extinct in a few decades. Most people would stop raising them, and if a few misguided folks would release flocks in the wild, those are in general not prepared to occupy an ecologic niche. They will either die off or wreck the environment of the region they were released at.

So, between options 1 and 2. The animals are going to die anyways, because if we did not expected to eat them, nobody would have bothered raising them. The only question left is how much suffering are they to endure in the process of dying. Proponents of #1 say this does not matter as long as the plate is full. Proponents of #2 say it is morally right to eat less meat in order to ensure the animals get killed in a more humane way.

How does your previous comment fits in that debate?

Re:The art of butchery by vacri on Sunday April 26, 2015 @10:12PM (#9444096)
What a strange dichotomy. Who is advocating for the torture of animals?
Re:The art of butchery by Falling3 on Monday April 27, 2015 @01:21AM (#9444492)
Directly? Very few. Indirectly? Almost everyone.
Re:The art of butchery by vacri on Monday April 27, 2015 @03:04AM (#9444746)
What is the animal analogue in that story, where the animals are tortured, then set free to live their own lives?