Judging from the anecdotal amount of blatantly "fake" accounts I've reported to Facebook, and seen nothing done about... I'd have to say that they don't "care" all that much short of plausible deniability. Accounts, likes, clicks, views are all currency to Facebook, which it trades to prospective companies in exchange for real money.
Example time.
FB get's 10 individual and separate reports for one specific account being fake. Let's assume this is some sort of "spike", and unusual. They then have an investigator manually check this account, and verify if it is a real account or not. If X people report it as fake, then it's likely a fake account, therefore human-intervention is required to confirm.
Then, stage two. After taking action, they note that those 10 individuals who reported this account matched the outcome of the human investigator. We could then infer that those accounts are:
A. Less likely to be fake themselves. And B. More reliable signals of fake accounts.
So, next time around. Perhaps the cumulative, or "enhanced" scoring of those accounts' reports requires a lower threshold for human intervention.
A cynical view would be: why are fake accounts bad for Facebook? These fake accounts help boost the number of users they report every quarter. These accounts don't use any server-side resources. They just sit around generating "likes", and with each "like" Facebook hears a cha-ching!
The argument presented in the article is that they do:
>These fake likes weren’t just an empty number. Whenever Second Floor Music posted content, Facebook’s algorithms placed it on the newsfeeds of a small, random sample of fans—the people who had liked Second Floor Music—and measured how many “engaged” with the content. High levels of engagement meant that the content was deemed interesting and redistributed to more fans for free—the main goal of most businesses that use social media is to reach this tipping point where content spreads virally. But the fake fans never engaged, depressing each post’s score and leaving it dead on arrival. The social media boost Bronstein had paid for never happened. Even worse, she now had thousands of fake fans who made it nearly impossible to reach her real fans. Bronstein struggled to get help from Facebook, reaching out repeatedly through help forums, but, in the end, she scrapped the original page and started again from scratch. Second Floor Music had effectively paid to ruin one of its flagship Facebook pages.
Sounds like a business opportunity. Fake fans who actually engage with content. They could even post fake comments and falsely claim they are planning to attend events. What a wonderful future we've built for ourselves.
We did not buy likes and I am not concerned with how many people like our page. I'm concerned with our engagement rate and reach -- which is (now) phenomenal. In the campaigns I have administered (after the incident that the article reported), I've created carefully targeted campaigns with high-quality copy. The New Republic article, however, discusses our first campaign, which was unfortunately low-quality and poorly targeted. Instead of learning that we hadn't created a good ad by seeing bad engagement, we learned by having our page overrun with fake likes who could not be removed. That's not a typical response for an ad buy, which is a real problem with Facebook's system.
Thanks for reading the story!
Rachel Bronstein, Web Editor, Second Floor Music
I wonder if facebook is working on such an update. One which would squash most of these click farms. I would think, given their resources, they would. The fact that they haven't yet leads me to believe they think this is a necessary evil and that they willingly allow it to continue.