That started me thinking outside the confines of the problem and about the implicit assumptions that were in the problem statement itself. The 'inability to piece everything together' is entirely imaginary on your part.
That's certainly a reasonable thing to do.
What's not reasonable is to assume that the assumptions you make are going to match the assumptions of others. Likewise, when make assumptions there is a chance that the assumptions you make are incorrect.
That may or may not be the case here.
But the fact remains, you need to make some very strong assumptions for what you have said to be true.
>> Given that this question is about humans
Please note that nowhere in the questions does it say the participants are human. This is one of your many assumptions.
If you can't piece everything together then... well you're not suited to logical analysis.