Re:Ask HN: Is it fair game to downvote someone's comments in...
by pen2l on Saturday April 25, 2015 @04:51PM
(#9439524)
I appreciate your thoughts, however it's already been established beyond doubt that rankbanning mechanisms exist and have been in effect for quite some time. I apologize for having called you out, I only did because people usually insist on getting "proof".
Re:Ask HN: Is it fair game to downvote someone's comments in...
by eli_gottlieb on Saturday April 25, 2015 @05:35PM
(#9439649)
Hmm. Interestingly, both of us are being downvoted in this very thread. I spent a whole post saying, "I don't mind automatic moderation mechanisms", and am apparently being downvoted for that.
Well, now I kinda do mind.
Re:Ask HN: Is it fair game to downvote someone's comments in...
by waterlesscloud on Saturday April 25, 2015 @05:12PM
(#9439580)
There was a time when "average karma" on your recent posts influenced your ranking. This was explicitly mentioned by pg at one point. However, dang has recently stated that avg karma has been removed and wasn't used for much anyway. So who knows?
That being said, downvoting due to disagreement is currently deeply harmful to this site, but the mods seem to be fine with it. Since that's their stance, I've taken to being quite liberal in my use of downvotes. If that's the way it is, it's dumb not to do the same.
That happened?
Ok, look, I don't count it a good thing, but I'd been assuming it was an automatic mechanism that kicks in when you take too many downvotes to one post. And my views are outright Marxist, not quasi-Marxist, but on some level, figuring out how to speak clearly across the massive inferential gap of "everyone else thinks Elizabeth Warren is solidly leftist and hasn't read all the same background literature as me" is my problem.
And besides which, I did get a number of emails based on that "Who wants to be hired?" post, and based on the "Who's hiring?" post for April I responded to an ad that ended up finding me a very nice new job.
So, overall, thanks for being angry on my behalf, but HN is really here for the business and technical stuff, for which it works well for me, and it really is my job to make my own points clear in a discussion.