Re:Effects from Filming the Adventures of Baron Munchausen (...
by stefantalpalaru on Saturday April 25, 2015 @06:38PM
(#9439779)
Yes, children don't understand satire because satire is complicated, but that won't affect their enjoyment of the movie. The satire is there for you, the adult stuck in a cinema for 90 minutes, watching yet another rehash of an old story.
Re:Effects from Filming the Adventures of Baron Munchausen (...
by btown on Saturday April 25, 2015 @04:40PM
(#9439496)
It seems like you're referencing some sort of psychology study or finding about children's reactions to Shrek - I was unaware that there was any child-psychology-based controversy about its use of satire whatsoever! Searches for "Shrek controversy" don't seem to mention anything nearly like this - do you have any references to the phenomenon you mention?
Re:Effects from Filming the Adventures of Baron Munchausen (...
by ctdonath on Saturday April 25, 2015 @05:53PM
(#9439688)
Yes: I'm a parent.
Re:Effects from Filming the Adventures of Baron Munchausen (...
by oldmanjay on Sunday April 26, 2015 @10:52AM
(#9441948)
that's interesting how you used the word yes but actually ended up not having the answer. certainly you didn't mean that as parent you feel that your emotion is a reference?
Re:Effects from Filming the Adventures of Baron Munchausen (...
by rdtsc on Saturday April 25, 2015 @09:21PM
(#9440149)
I think any popular and kids movie will insert innuendos, sarcasm and things like that in there. I suspect that often addressed for the adults. In other words it is a multi-layered thing going on. I don't know which cartoons but some have had pretty adult references in there, but it would take an adult to understand. Kids might ask "hey, why are you laughing?".
However I agree with the idea of positive vs negative framework in general. And think there is even a temporal dimension in it. By that I mean that almost all childrens' shows have some kind of a conflict in the beginning -- someone behaving badly, someone being shamed, ignored, maybe not sharing, or other negative behavior like that. Later in the story that is resolved and the protagonist learns a life lesson -- "ok, be nice to your friends", "listen to your parents" etc. Except the problem is at a certain age children cannot follow the continuity of the story they just see a character fighting, behaving badly, etc and they copy it.
Re:Effects from Filming the Adventures of Baron Munchausen (...
by vacri on Saturday April 25, 2015 @11:01PM
(#9440361)
I'm curious as to what you see in Shrek-without-satire that is harmful to children. What's the negative foundation that it builds?
Re:Effects from Filming the Adventures of Baron Munchausen (...
by ChristianGeek on Sunday April 26, 2015 @02:59AM
(#9440811)
Actually, I thought it was kind of a dick response on Gilliam's part. He completely dismisses her feelings at the time and the effect the experience had on her by half-heartedly assuring her she was safer than she thought, and then immediately goes on to ask her how well he did with her body double.
TL;DR - a child star of a Terry Gilliam film writes him, decades later, to describe the sheer terror she felt acting out the film and how that terror caused her social/emotional problems growing up; Gilliam responds in surprise/confusion/appreciation, lauding how solid an actor she was at age 9, and unaware of the effect it had on her.