It wouldn't have taken you so long if you had've just been doing logic in a classroom. This isn't a puzzle that was sprung on the students by surprise; it was part of their course.
Re:When Is Cheryl's Birthday?
by lifeisstillgood on Saturday April 25, 2015 @03:52AM
(#9437607)
Trust me that is a very eloquent and perceptive explanation of your own failings, and how that applies to others experience. Whatever time limit was arbitrarily set for the "test" you pass the more important test with flying colours.
After eliminating May and June because they have unique days, which is obvious, I got stuck trying to figure out how Albert would be able to figure out the date after knowing that Bernard now knows the date. So I got stuck on July 16, Aug. 15 and Aug. 17 for a while, because I could not figure out how Albert would know the date if he was told August as the month. It took me a few minutes (ok, like 5 or so, more then I care to admit to my self I suppose :) ) to figure out that my job wasn't to figure out how Albert new, but rather to figure out what the answer was IF Albert now knew the answer.
From that it's pretty easy, but it's the perspective that trips most people up.