News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Photography Was Optimized for White Skin Color by briandear on Friday April 24, 2015 @07:58PM (#9436592)
I disagree with this nonsense. I was a photojournalist for Reuters during the tail end of the film era; 1996-2002 and the issue with black subjects had nothing to do with color balance but of the latitude of the film; we used Fuji almost exclusively and since I did tons of sports and low light spot news, It was mostly 800 speed occasionally pushed hard.

Shooting NBA meant I had mostly black subjects. The film didn't discriminate: in most arenas if the time, we shot at 500/2.8; for a darker arena, we'd increase the processing time (or if we had an especially important shot, increase the chemical temperature, effectively overclocking the processing.) my point is that dark skin or light, the color balance made no difference; it was about exposure. Since we held shutter speed and aperture constant (2.8 was the fastest aperture for 400mm lenses and anything below 1/500th would get motion blur,) our exposures were relatively constant regardless of the subject's skin color. The problem is if you have a bunch of white guys and one black guy, auto-metering would expose in such a way as to render the scene equal to an 18% grey card. So the black guy would be under exposed. However, if you took a photo with 20 black guys and 1 white guy, the white guy would look like he was made out of white light: he'd be dramatically overexposed because autometering it exposed for 18% grey. If you had used an incident light meter, generally the scenes would be fine because the meter wouldn't be trying to 'grey card' the scene.

As far as Jean Luc and his 'racist' Kodachrome, I suspect that's apocryphal. Kodachrome is notoriously difficult to expose correctly; meaning you typically want to expose for highlights because it has a very narrow latitude and blasting out highlights is a real concern. There's nothing racist about it, it is just a very difficult film to light correctly, especially if he were shooting on location in Africa.

But what do I know, I am a white guy so I obviously don't quite understand the struggle to make everything into some kind of racist conspiracy.

The fact is that if film were racist, Spike Lee and others would have been screaming about it. This is the first I've ever heard of this theory and I was a film junkie for a long time as well as a fan of Ernest Dickerson and Bob Richardson; never once have those guys mentioned racist color balance. The argument is just absurd.

If we want to talk about racism in Hollywood, we have about a million potential topics, but film stock isn't one of them. What next, lenses are racist?

Re:How Photography Was Optimized for White Skin Color by fennecfoxen on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:32PM (#9436674)
Just to give people an idea of the numbers we're working with here:

According to The Internets and Google (who know everything and are NEVER WRONG), Kodachrome's dynamic range was about 7.3 stops (so your whitest white is 2^(7.3) ~= 157 times brighter than your blackest black). Kodachrome was a color positive film (i.e. slides). Slide film is notorious for being tricky to expose right.

For comparison, a nice modern black-and-white negative film like Kodak Tri-X 400 has a range of about 13.5 stops (white is 11,585x brighter than black). It's also 2-8 times as sensitive overall as Kodachrome (which came from ISO 25 to ISO 200) and probably has comparable or smaller grain size.

(Of course, black and white is easier, and a better comparison would be Kodak Portra, but I couldn't Google up the numbers readily enough to present here.)

Re:How Photography Was Optimized for White Skin Color by briandear on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:38PM (#9436692)
Thanks for those numbers! I couldn't remember the exacts.. Another difficulty of Chrome films where that the color would shift badly if you pushed or pulled it. You could push and pull, but not as much as negative film.

The crazy thing is that Nat Geo shot almost entirely on Kodachrome and their photos remain some of the most amazing ever created. They'd often shoot with just available light as well. Incredible stuff.

Re:How Photography Was Optimized for White Skin Color by danilocampos on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:09PM (#9436618)
So you worked with film at the apex of its technological development and that makes you an expert on the beginning of the color era, when that technology was exceptionally expensive?

Cool story, bro.

Re:How Photography Was Optimized for White Skin Color by briandear on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:29PM (#9436667)
Do you have any facts or relevant anecdotes to add to the discussion? I am very interested in other points of view. I don't claim to be right, I am only attempting to add to the discussion, providing a counterpoint to the claims made by the article. If you have some evidence supporting the article's premise, let's have it! I'd love to see more evidence about racism in photography.

It seems like your main goal is to affirm your closely held core beliefs that everything and everyone is racist. The world isn't so black and white. Not everything is a conspiracy against the black man. You also might realize that there is certainly an incentive to fan the fires of sanctimony. There's an entire industry of people who have a vested interest in finding racism under every rock.

Let's just allow for a second that film is racist. So what? What are you going to do about it? Maintaining your rage or perhaps doing something positive to actually make the world a better place? Look forward; Don't let your own hatred stunt your potential to do something positive! Chips on shoulders can be exhausting!

Re:How Photography Was Optimized for White Skin Color by danilocampos1 on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:48PM (#9436715)
Remember that time where you had no idea the racist history of public swimming pools, but still wanted to be treated as an expert on what made things racist?

Ah, good times.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9436623

Re:How Photography Was Optimized for White Skin Color by brandonmenc on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:58PM (#9436738)
It's obvious he was referring to the physical characteristics of swimming pools. You mistakenly put the "public" in there.
Re:How Photography Was Optimized for White Skin Color by danilocampos1 on Friday April 24, 2015 @09:06PM (#9436761)
Oh, obviously. We very conveniently live in a world, after all, where physical constructs are always divorced from structures of power and politics.
Re:How Photography Was Optimized for White Skin Color by coldtea on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:30PM (#9436669)
First, he worked with film (as did I). Did you? And what exactly makes the author of TFA an expert on the subject?

Second, film wasn't a technology solidified in the "beginning of the color era", color reproduction and emulsions changed all the time, and new films with different color repro and dynamic range were appearing frequently.

Re:How Photography Was Optimized for White Skin Color by vernie on Friday April 24, 2015 @09:14PM (#9436772)
You appear to be mad, bro.