This page has been online for a while, and it still appears to be limited to a very small, select number of publishers. Did anyone request an invitation and actually receive an invite during the last 5 months?
I'm assuming this is another Google service that'll die before I'm able to try it.
Re:Contributor by Google
by Zikes on Friday April 24, 2015 @02:34PM
(#9435212)
My biggest concern with this is that it is still so integrated into the ads system. I don't use AdBlock and its kin solely because I don't want to see the ads, but also so that I am not tracked everywhere I go on the internet. This does not seem to address that.
Re:Contributor by Google
by Zikes on Friday April 24, 2015 @02:40PM
(#9435253)
If the service were launched as a wholly separate entity, with clearly stated legal terms for data privacy and retention, I would be able to accept that as a necessity.
Re:Contributor by Google
by arielm on Friday April 24, 2015 @02:46PM
(#9435288)
> "When you visit a participating website, part of your contribution goes to the creators of that site."
Umm, why does Google have to control this sort of ad-prevention mechanic? Obviously because it lets them profit from potential lost ad revenue, but what about the publishers? What sort of "cut" are they getting? And why are they only getting a cut of contributions that are essentially for their content?
The advertising business is getting really messy...
I just stumbled on this link, and apparently you can stop contributing to specific sites, and also select whether to contributor to all participating sites, or ones you specifically select.
It looks overpriced. I need to be signed into my Google account at all times when browsing the internet, pay $10-15/mo, and even then, it's only removing something like 50-75% of advertisements. It's more expensive than ad block, it removes less ads than ad block, and it leaves a big empty space that ad block can typically remove.
This sounds like a poor experience for the end user, and I can't see it catching on.
I'm assuming this is another Google service that'll die before I'm able to try it.
Umm, why does Google have to control this sort of ad-prevention mechanic? Obviously because it lets them profit from potential lost ad revenue, but what about the publishers? What sort of "cut" are they getting? And why are they only getting a cut of contributions that are essentially for their content?
The advertising business is getting really messy...
http://www.droid-life.com/2015/04/21/this-is-google-contribu...
It looks overpriced. I need to be signed into my Google account at all times when browsing the internet, pay $10-15/mo, and even then, it's only removing something like 50-75% of advertisements. It's more expensive than ad block, it removes less ads than ad block, and it leaves a big empty space that ad block can typically remove.
This sounds like a poor experience for the end user, and I can't see it catching on.