Re:Job Interview 2.0: Now With Riddles
by Elepsis on Sunday November 15, 2009 @12:17PM
(#943088)
While I agree with the general thought about the interview, the last example question has nothing to do with riddles and falls into a completely different category: designing with constraints.
In a job where a significant part of your responsibility is figuring out how a feature should work, and balancing that with a variety of obligations (accessibility, security, resources, what partner teams need), asking a question like 'how would you modify a bicycle to make it suitable for the blind?' is a reasonable way to see a person's approach to working through various aspects of a design and weighing different features without relying purely on domain knowledge of a specific area of software.
Re:Job Interview 2.0: Now With Riddles
by jlees on Sunday November 15, 2009 @01:12PM
(#943146)
The bike-for-the-blind question is a totally reasonable type of question, but a stupid example IMO. It could either be a common sense test or a constrained-thinking test, and isn't clear which it should be.
In a job where a significant part of your responsibility is figuring out how a feature should work, and balancing that with a variety of obligations (accessibility, security, resources, what partner teams need), asking a question like 'how would you modify a bicycle to make it suitable for the blind?' is a reasonable way to see a person's approach to working through various aspects of a design and weighing different features without relying purely on domain knowledge of a specific area of software.