"Starve the beast", remember?
How much bloody staff do you need to take a peek at the securities kept at a fund's bank account? We aren't talking "complex" stuff like rating agencies putting AAA ratings on junk (and BTW S&P was slapped on its wrist with a >$1B fine over that after an investigation). We're talking about a guy with almost no staff who paid "returns on investments" from his pool of investments.
The sum of the securities he'd keep would thus fall far behind the number following from his reports. Not noticing can only result from not checking. Not checking that much after multiple warnings results from defunding?! Perhaps, if there was just the janitor left and all the regulators were fired. Was that the case?
(You know what could be a probable cause other than incompetence or taking bribes? A desire to be employed by a Wall Street firm after resigning as a regulator, and a belief that it wouldn't work out if Madoff were checked and found clean, or even if checked and found guilty. But is it more than a convoluted bribe?)
Your assumption they were either bribed or incompetent is unwarranted.
If the SEC cannot look at the actual balance sheet as maintained by banks etc. until "the wheels come off" and until then they can only rely on what the org says its balance sheet is, things are really bad but somehow I doubt that's the case.
No, actually. This is wrong. You can't spot a clever Ponzi scheme if the person who provides the balance sheet is willing to put down false information.
As an auditor all you can do is correlate the bits of information you have. If the criminal is intelligent you won't spot anything until it's too late.
The "warnings" they got were that Madoff's fund was making money too consistently. That's useless.
As to the warnings being useless - you mean that the likelihood of such warnings does not correlate with the real state of things enough to justify action? As in, every legitimate money manager is suspected by many competitors of being a fraud and the SEC is overwhelmed with meaningless warnings to that effect? I doubt it somehow.
1. Were Madoff's regulators fired? (My guess: they weren't, it wasn't even weighed as a realistic option by whoever should fire them.)
2. Was there an investigation into whether they were bribed, as there should be when someone is so spectacularly incompetent at their job that it's hard to reconcile with having the mental skills necessary to get the job in the first place? (My bet: there was no investigation whatsoever.)