News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by trevelyan on Thursday April 23, 2015 @02:12PM (#9428662)
There are some interesting ideas buried in his writing (panopticon) but Foucault's ideas aren't consistent and it isn't even clear that he takes them seriously himself. Discipline & Punish is also pretty elevated nonsense.

The book makes sense as a history of penal reform, and Foucault is right to point out that changes often served to better punish prisoners rather than reform them as the rhetoric of the day demanded. But pointing out public hypocrisy is hardly a sophisticated observation for a historian to make. And it is a weak base from which to launch the sweeping attack Foucault attempts on the idea that morality matters, or to insist that man's "soul" is nothing more than his position in power networks or that "power" itself is "knowledge" (not vice versa).

In order to support these points, Foucault is dishonest on so many basic historical points that it calls the honesty of his actual historical research into question. I have a ton of underlined passages in my copy of D&P which I made with increasing frequency as his claims started to contradict each other. In the interest of just picking one, look at Foucault's insistence that democratization had absolutely nothing to do with efforts to remove the death penalty. Really? And Foucault "proves" his opinion not by citing a single document but rather by simply stating his opinion that "executions did not, in fact, frighten the people."

Well which is it? Are we truly to believe that the horrific demonstrations of torture which Foucault spends entire chapters chronicling (salaciously, like pornography) did not frighten anyone? Why if so does he describe them in such detailed fashion? And doesn't his own claim about the ineffectiveness of the punishment now contradict his earlier statements about the nature of knowledge, to say nothing of his earlier chapters which actually documented how people were, in practice, quite terrorized.

A lot of the dishonesty slides by in the sheer minutiae of death. And it all gives the impression that Foucault must be right, if only because he is able to a picture of humanity that would repulse most honest people and do so unflinchingly (the virtue of facing unpleasant truths!). But at a certain point, the discerning reader recognizes his sophistry for what it is and stops trying to make sense of it all. I'd encourage anyone on HN to go directly to Plato if they want real philosophy, or at least jump back to Nietzsche (Schopenhauer as Educator) if they want an entertaining and tongue-in-cheek iconoclast whose ideas merit real thought.

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by benbreen on Thursday April 23, 2015 @06:24PM (#9430285)
I'm an early modern historian of science so I'm sympathetic to arguments about Foucault's ahistorical tendencies. My biggest gripe with him is that he tends to conflate "the world" or "the West" with what often seems to be Paris and its environs, when you look at what he's actually citing. But then again, that's a complaint you can lob against many 20th century French historians.

On the other hand, he really is an excellent historian of ideas and of early modern science; maybe a little less empirically grounded than historians from the "Anglo-Saxon" world like me might prefer, but you can't deny the usefulness of his ideas. He's also quite a good prose stylist in many passages, much more lively and original than the other names (like Derrida, who I find opaque and boring) with whom he's often lumped together. His opening description of Las Meninas by Velazquez in The Order of Things is one of the passages that made me want to study what I do.

To get a little pedantic though (because I'm enjoying this discussion), more recent historians of violence and executions basically support the specific claim you call into question (that executions typically didn't frighten early modern audiences). People like Edward Muir at Northwestern have done great original work in Italian archives to show just how different attitudes toward public violence were in the premodern world. [1] An execution was literally something you'd take your kids to and buy refreshments at, like a play. I don't see the conflict between that claim, which is quite robust on an empirical level, and Foucault describing gory details that shock his modern audience - just because we find it frightening doesn't mean our great-great-great-great-grandparents did.

[1] https://books.google.com/books?id=zlULqJ70bDUC&q=executions#...

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by tjradcliffe on Thursday April 23, 2015 @06:36PM (#9430341)
And just because people took their kids doesn't mean they didn't find it frightening. The two claims have literally nothing to do with each other. It's like saying people pay good money to see horror movies so they aren't scared of being hacked to bits by psychopaths.

Native peoples in the Great Lakes region mostly enjoyed torturing prisoners of war to death in variously fairly horrible ways, often over days. The whole tribe participated and it had something of the carnivalesque atmosphere the link you provide mentions. Yet there is also evidence that fear of capture loomed very large in the minds of warriors because of the fate that awaited them.

One of the things the post-structuralists (especially Derida, who is really nothing but a troll) are good at is distraction and indirection. Foucault's bloodthirsty descriptions of torture in D&P have no scholarly value and could easily be replaced by a one-or-two-line sketch of the reality without loss of utility... except that people would then read the rest of the book in a less aroused state of mind, and would be more calmly critical of his unsupported and frequently implausible claims.

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by benbreen on Thursday April 23, 2015 @06:46PM (#9430388)
It seems to me that you're conflating too different manifestations of fear - the fear of the crowd that watched executions and a larger societal fear of governmental or judicial violence. No one who has read primary sources from the period we're talking about would argue that the latter didn't exist; as for the former, like Muir points out, it could manifest many different ways, from howls of fear to laughter and jokes. In the end we can never say definitively what was running through the heads of everyone in a crowd 400 years ago, but it's not just Foucault making stuff up or trying to trick his audience when he writes about attitudes toward early modern executions. It really is there in the original sources. Here's just one case in point, from the dairy of Samuel Pepys:

Saturday 13 October 1660 To my Lord’s in the morning, where I met with Captain Cuttance, but my Lord not being up I went out to Charing Cross, to see Major-general Harrison hanged, drawn, and quartered; which was done there, he looking as cheerful as any man could do in that condition. He was presently cut down, and his head and heart shown to the people, at which there was great shouts of joy.

http://www.pepysdiary.com/diary/1660/10/13/

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by trevelyan on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:35PM (#9434802)
* who exactly is the subject of terror, the person executed or the crowd? At the start of his book Foucault seems to claim that the subject is the person being executed. But then he shifts to talking about the attitude of the crowd.

* we are probably meant to view them as equivalents because of class consciousness and the Marxist digressions about man having no "soul" except for his position in power networks. But... but... surely it was quite common that the crowd and the person executed had quite different attitudes towards the event.

* also, if capital punishment was really ineffective at inducing terror (in whom?), why were 19th century French penal reformers the first ones to notice? isn't it weird that this enlightenment corresponded with a public debate over morality if the two events are unrelated?

* more substantively, if Foucault is right and French penal reformers were the first ones to notice for whatever reason, doesn't his pointing this out imply the existence of an objective standard of knowledge that undermines Foucault his claims elsewhere about power being wisdom and truth being subjective?

Uggg... I could go on for a while. Enough Foucault.

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by coldtea on Thursday April 23, 2015 @08:27PM (#9430782)
>But pointing out public hypocrisy is hardly a sophisticated observation for a historian to make.

Actually it's a very useful role for a philosopher, one cherished from the time of Socrates down to Nietchze, Adorno, Christopher Lasch, and almost everybody else in between.

>Well which is it? Are we truly to believe that the horrific demonstrations of torture which Foucault spends entire chapters chronicling (salaciously, like pornography) did not frighten anyone?

Yes. And in fact you can find tons of sources stating that they were kind of public spectacles, with women, children and others participating -- even until down to the early 20th century.

>Why if so does he describe them in such detailed fashion?

This question does not follow from anything. You essentially ask "if they didn't frighten anything, why does he describe them in such detailed fashion" -- as if how detailed their descriptions are, is supposed to be affected by whether they frightened people. I, for one, fail to see any mystery or contradiction. You can describe in minute detail also stuff that doesn't frighten people.

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by krakensden on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:27PM (#9431276)
>> Why if so does he describe them in such detailed fashion?

> This question does not follow from anything

Presumably he's dog whistling about Foucault's sexual preferences.

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by trevelyan on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:55AM (#9431500)
The point has nothing to do with anyone's sexuality. It is that Foucault writes in a way designed to elicit an emotional reaction from the reader (distress at the graphic depiction of human suffering), and yet denies the existence of the same emotional reaction when it comes to attributing motives for penal reform.

As for his flatly contradicting himself, opening his own book a practically random page brings up the following quote from a contemporary (Damhoudere) complaining that Foucault's executioners exercise "every cruelty with regard to the evil-doing patients, treating them, buffeting and killing them as if they had a beast in their hands." The fact that executions were public spectacles did not mean that people approached them with expectations of justice.

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by coldtea on Friday April 24, 2015 @08:33AM (#9432839)
>* It is that Foucault writes in a way designed to elicit an emotional reaction from the reader (distress at the graphic depiction of human suffering), and yet denies the existence of the same emotional reaction when it comes to attributing motives for penal reform.*

He writes to elicit that emotion to readers many decades (or centuries, depending on the specific practice) removed from those practices. Doesn't mean the people back then had the same emotions or those were the ones that brought the reform.

Reading about the treatment of slaves in the South today will get a huge emotional response too, but that was not how slavery was abolished then -- it took a whole civil war (and decades of struggles with prejudice, Jim Crow laws, KKK and segregation).

>As for his flatly contradicting himself, opening his own book a practically random page brings up the following quote from a contemporary (Damhoudere) complaining that Foucault's executioners exercise "every cruelty with regard to the evil-doing patients, treating them, buffeting and killing them as if they had a beast in their hands." The fact that executions were public spectacles did not mean that people approached them with expectations of justice.

Where's the contradiction? What some public figures and intellectuals said of the executions is not the same as what the public sentiment about them.

To continue with the same exampke, that's in the same way that there were several prominents pro-abolitionists in the South, but that was not the prevalent sentiment of the people there.

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by thwest on Friday April 24, 2015 @04:22AM (#9432018)
Perhaps prison is more frightening than executions.
Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by thwest on Thursday April 23, 2015 @05:52PM (#9430111)
> Foucault "proves" his opinion not by citing a single document but rather by simply stating his opinion that "executions did not, in fact, frighten the people."

That quote is the concluding sentence of a paragraph which cites at least three documents:

* Argenson, 241

* Hardy IV, 56

* Richet, 118-19

Does your copy have the parenthetical citations removed?

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by trevelyan on Friday April 24, 2015 @12:36PM (#9434401)
None of those references are relevant to the quote in question, which attributes very specific and cynical beliefs to 19th penal reformers in ways which explicitly conflict with their own writings.
Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by thwest on Friday April 24, 2015 @03:19PM (#9435477)
Do you care to cite those conflicts? Are 18th century reformers beyond a mote of cynicism? That sentence isn't claiming to describe the entire world view of the reformers, but to specifically note that they would have been aware of the number of examples where the masses were not deterred by the spectacle of executions. (You seem to take offense with specificity in a claim?)

It is possible to declare the system of executions a travesty, while also observing that the lower classes are willing to phsyically intervene in them. Perhaps it is even possible that the reformers were made aware of the injustices by the lack of respect the lower classes demonstrated for them.

Perhaps a reformer with the goal of abolishing executions would pen a treatise that was justified in the moral terms of the ruling class, rather than based on the emotional state of the working class. One would look to address your audience after all. I'm not familiar with the cited reformers you claim are conflicting but it sounds more like aristocracy convincing aristocracy, rather than an aristocrat attempting to sway the masses with pamphlets.

I question whether you read this text in good faith, or are simply searching for bits you can pick out to summarize on a message board and construe as contradictions.

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by trevelyan on Saturday April 25, 2015 @11:07PM (#9440383)
> I question whether you read this text in good faith...

What is good faith? You're picking a small (although perfectly valid -- re-read Part II for whatever quotes you need on the self-professed motives of penal reformers) objection pulled pretty much at random from my marginalia rather than addressing the more substantive complaints in my original post.

And even here your defense is speculative ("perhaps") and offered in a non-committal way that ironically conflicts with Foucault's own viewpoint by subsuming the problem in a moral framework ("travesty") rather than contextualizing it as a power struggle in an amoral Marxist context. So even if your defense is correct then Foucault's sweeping ontological statements are inappropriate and overbearing, which is part of my complaint.

If you want to focus on bigger ideas, I've posted four more major complaints in a post above. If you are able to explain what Foucault means without making his position sound absurd and/or contradicting his own writing, you'll have done a better job explaining his ideas than he did.

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by Crito on Thursday April 23, 2015 @05:01PM (#9429786)
My favourite account of Plato involves one of his alleged interactions with Diogenes. As told by wikipedia:

> "When Plato gave Socrates' definition of man as "featherless bipeds" and was much praised for the definition, Diogenes plucked a chicken and brought it into Plato's Academy, saying, "Behold! I've brought you a man." After this incident, "with broad flat nails" was added to Plato's definition."

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by trevelyan on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:37PM (#9434820)
That's a great story. Crito is my favorite of the dialogues as well. Too bad I can only upvote you once.