News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by steveklabnik on Thursday April 23, 2015 @01:33PM (#9428345)
There's a lot of different ways to tackle this problem, obviously, so I'll just point you in one of many directions. You'd have to consult the specific thinker's works to get their exact takes.

Okay, so the concept of 'human nature' in general needs some more definition, like you've said. Here's maybe a better phrasing of the problem: "Do humans have some sort of _innate_ properties that are shared amongst all humans?" This phrasing calls back to an old debate in philosophy: essentialism. This is a question of ontology, in other words, what kinds of things are there in the world, and how do we categorize them?

An essentialist takes the position that we can form categories of things by defining some set of properties, and then any entity which has those properties is one of those things. In other words, let's say something like "You're a human as long as you have a name." This is a position which is essentialist. And that might be a workable definition.

A non-essentialist may come along and challenge your ontology, though. "Ships also have names, but they are clearly not human." You may agree with this, and so you need to revise your set of properties. "Humans are things that have names, and walk on two legs." The non-essentialist may respond, "birds have names, and when they walk, they use two legs. Your ontology is incorrect.

You see where this is going. Those who take a position against essentialism claim that this approach to categorization is a folly. It's fundamentally broken.. To give you a counterpoint, I generally agree with a process philosophy, which means that I equate identity with _doing_, not with _being_. An example of a process philosopher's standpoint on ontology: "You're a Rubyist if you write Ruby code." This kind of categorization is more useful, because over time, my identity can change. I might be a Rubyist for a while, but at some point, I wasn't. And I might stop being one in the future, too. An approached based on do-ing includes things like a time component that an essentialist position never can.

So, returning to the original question, no, the question of an inherent nature doesn't make any sense, and therefore, neither does 'human nature'. So where do we go from there? Well, any claim that's reliant on an appeal to human nature is incorrect. For example, "Humans are inherently greedy."

Anyway, that's a hastily-typed overview of a concept in a HN comment, but hopefully that helps you get the gist of it.

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by MichaelGG on Thursday April 23, 2015 @01:53PM (#9428503)
How is that different than arguing over definitions?

In particular, delineating humans has the same problems as separating any species. You can have a group B that can interbreed with A and C, but A and C can't. Has anything useful come out of getting worked up over what to call species A, B, and C?

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by steveklabnik on Thursday April 23, 2015 @02:01PM (#9428560)
> How is that different than arguing over definitions?

Definitions are very important. For example, one of the defining movements from second to third wave feminism was a move from essentialism. Second-wave essentialism couldn't handle the 1% of intersex people, for example, or the existence of trans individuals. (this is of course not the only thing that separates them, just one example)

These kinds of questions are full of real-world implications. This stuff matters when it comes down to questions like healthcare, and if some procedure is covered, for example. Any law which affects people based on some criteria. That's a lot of laws.

> In particular, delineating humans has the same problems as separating any species.

Absolutely, which is an other example of where this issue raises its head. Ontology is very relevant to many, many fields.

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by detcader on Thursday April 23, 2015 @04:03PM (#9429451)
"Second-wave essentialism couldn't handle the 1% of intersex people, for example, or the existence of trans individuals."

What a dishonest attempt at a characterization. You took the opporunity of the readers' unfamiliarity with a topic to interject your own subjective and vague opinion ("Second-wave essentiallism couldn't handle" -- what function does this phrase even serve beyond emotional release for the writer? What does it even mean?), without providing any links or citations to the extensive existing material that exists.

If you valued actual discourse, you would link to some article like Michelle Goldberg's "What is a Woman?"[0] in the New Yorker to provide some sort of context on the conflicting ideas of feminism and queer theory. But time and time again my fellow men who cheerlead for queer theory and identity politics bring nothing to the table but opportunistic, ingenuine rhetoric bordering on non-sequitur. I don't even need to claim anything about second-wave or modern radical feminists -- the transparently anti-intellectual liberal male digs his own grave.

[0] http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2014/08/04/woman-2

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by steveklabnik on Thursday April 23, 2015 @04:36PM (#9429634)
As always, everything is presented at a certain level of abstraction. I was alluding to TERFs, whose 'e' stands for 'exclusionary,' ie, they exclude trans women from their idea of 'woman.' As with any summary, it of course glosses over details, and is clearly biased by who is speaking. It seems a bit strange to have to state that in a thread about Foucault. You are totally correct that my bias lies with queer theory.
Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by detcader on Thursday April 23, 2015 @05:02PM (#9429791)
I did understand who you were alluding to. But for those unfamiliar, are you implying that modern and historical feminists who have a conception of the oppression of women that you and some people in Queer Theroy and some tumblr users disagree with, coined the name "TERF", rather than the latter group? An uninformed reader would possibly take away that some number of feminists actually, non-ironically, take on the label "TERF". In my time in reading dozens of writers on these issues, which has been at least a year now, I've never seen this. So hopefully that wasn't the implication.

If one's confidence in one's own bias is such that one can inject it into discourse without feeling the need to cite any material which asserts ideas which they are biased "against" ("Second-wave essentiallism", whatever that entails), or even import material supporting their own claims, would one not mind if another was to comment with some reading material for those who may be interested in this thread? For example, the 2013 letter "Forbidden Discourse: The Silencing of Feminist Criticism of 'Gender'" written by 37 second-wave and modern radical feminists [0], or the essay "SSCAB/DSCAB: Reconsidering the Conversation" written by a black radical feminist [1], or glosswitch's "Beauty and the cis" [2]? Surely it shouldn't change anything to point out that these writings exist.

[0] reprinted here: https://gendertrender.wordpress.com/2013/08/21/authenticity-...

[1] https://bmgnedra.wordpress.com/2014/03/28/sscabdscab-reframi...

[2] http://glosswatch.com/2014/04/20/beauty-and-the-cis/

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by steveklabnik on Thursday April 23, 2015 @06:10PM (#9430217)
> rather than the latter group?

I didn't make any claims about the origin of the term. Your history is accurate, to my knowledge.

> without feeling the need to cite any material

This isn't a dissertation. It's HN. Not every last thing needs a citation.

And no, I don't 'mind' at all. I'm very sympathetic to many arguments made here. People should read second-wave stuff. I just come down on a different side of them, personally.

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by sedachv on Thursday April 23, 2015 @09:45PM (#9430994)
> In particular, delineating humans has the same problems as separating any species. You can have a group B that can interbreed with A and C, but A and C can't. Has anything useful come out of getting worked up over what to call species A, B, and C?

That assertion is a good illustration of the problem some Continental philosophers tried to address - what is a "species" and how is it defined? It's an arbitrary labeling we put on a collection of individuals that we perceive to have similarities.

This kind of thinking is exactly what lead Chomsky into the erroneous theories of Universal Grammar and the Language Acquisition Device. Studying real neurons in actual brains is what got linguistics out of the generative grammar dead-end: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistics_Wars

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by calibraxis on Thursday April 23, 2015 @05:48PM (#9430093)
If there's no human nature, what keeps you from being a dog?
Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by steveklabnik on Thursday April 23, 2015 @06:03PM (#9430189)
From what angle? Is this question "How do we differentiate between species" or "what stops us from killing anyone" or "what makes human life more valuable, if it even is, than an animal's?"
Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by calibraxis on Thursday April 23, 2015 @06:37PM (#9430348)
People believe there's a dog-nature, just as much as they believe there's a human-nature. Regardless of the philosophical position they profess.

(It is part of our nature to have constraints keeping us from being dogs. Anyone who wishes to prove otherwise is welcome to become a dog.)

In your argument against human nature, you stated: "An essentialist takes the position that we can form categories of things by defining some set of properties". But that's seems a strawman definition in this context, because no one can even define a chair. Much less a human. Fortunately, people who believe in the concept of human nature (virtually everyone) don't need to sit around making futile constructivist definitions.

Re:Foucault’s lecture notes from 1970–71 demolish caricature... by steveklabnik on Thursday April 23, 2015 @06:49PM (#9430402)
> Anyone who wishes to prove otherwise is welcome to become a dog.

Saying that there's no essential dog-nature does not inherently imply that one can become a dog.

> (virtually everyone)

Yes, Plato and Aristotle were essentialists, and you can't possibly over-state their influence on Western thought. But, I would argue that your 'everyone' includes many non-philosphers, who haven't necessarily considered this problem in the depth that philosophers have. That doesn't mean that essentialism is disproven or anything! But rightfully, in my mind anyway, a number of schools of thought take issue with it, just like any other position.

That said, actually, it depends on who you're talking to.

> that's seems a strawman definition in this context

It's not! That's the problem itself: you're absolutely right that defining what is a chair and what is human is very difficult.