News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by rrss1122 on Thursday April 23, 2015 @10:48AM (#9427076)
"It seems like Apple is doing that as a way to kill competition and promote their own watch, which is fair from a business standpoint."

It's nowhere near fair. It's extremely anticompetitive. This is the kind of behavior that gets a company in trouble with the FTC.

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by LordKano on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:23AM (#9427314)
This is the kind of behavior that gets a company in trouble with the FTC.

Indeed but Apple is aware that the FTC isn't likely to punish them enough that the behavior will be a net negative.

If only the Federal Government would be as serious about "Sending a message" on antitrust as they are about low-mid level drug dealers, this kind of thing would be a lot more rare.

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by xbmcuser on Thursday April 23, 2015 @12:41PM (#9427965)
FTC won't but European union probably will plus in Europe they fine you a percentage of total revenue of company which for Apple could be over 15billion.

   My recommendation to any one developing for apple devices is be ready to be blocked or kicked out of the app store if you are too successful. As apple will enter the market and if they do they will start applying rules they were ignoring earlier as those were selling devices for them but now they don't need you as you are a competitor so out you go.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by Sir_Substance on Thursday April 23, 2015 @03:46PM (#9429330)
>Indeed but Apple is aware that the FTC isn't likely to punish them enough that the behavior will be a net negative.

That makes it correct game theory, Apple has to do it because every other company does it. So it's necessary, but that doesn't make it fair.

So apparently the FTC won't punish them enough for it to be a net negative. Oh well, I guess that's it then. No one else has responsibility, right?

Wrong!

We have responsibility. The good news is, you don't have to work hard at it. If you want to punish apple for this, just stop buying their shit. It's actually easier than not doing it!

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by cududa on Thursday April 23, 2015 @12:41PM (#9427967)
But Apple doesn't have anywhere near a monopoly on smart phones, so being anti-competitive is completely legal
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by digi_owl on Thursday April 23, 2015 @02:11PM (#9428645)
Monopoly is a smokescreen word. Antitrust is not about monopoly, it is about abuse of market position.

If your company has 10% of the market, and the rest has 1% each, you can still be slapped for antitrust if you start using that position as leverage in a different market.

ianal, btw...

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by moskie on Thursday April 23, 2015 @03:44PM (#9429322)
What are examples of companies being penalized for antitrust while not being a monopoly (or part of an oligopoly)?
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by yellowapple on Thursday April 23, 2015 @10:44PM (#9431148)
Well, there's Microsoft, which has been penalized on various occasions in the States and the EU despite not actually being a monopoly (there were plenty of other operating system vendors out there, Apple among them).

And then you have Google, which has been taking quite a bit of flak from Europe lately.

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by moskie on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:04AM (#9433337)
I'm sorry, could you be more specific? Please link to specific cases that meet the criteria (antitrust cases where the company is found guilty of anti-competitive practices that do NOT involve the company abusing their (mon|olig)opoly power in a certain market). Both those companies are involved in many cases, antitrust or otherwise, and I'm unable to find one that fits the bill. I think you (and digi_owl) are incorrect.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by yellowapple on Friday April 24, 2015 @03:03PM (#9435386)
Neither of them were or are actually monopolies (Google isn't the only search engine in the world, and Microsoft wasn't the only PC operating system vendor in the world even during the 90's), so literally any of the cases you've found would be applicable.

An antitrust case can still be levied for conspiring to become a monopoly (as Microsoft did with its strongarming of OEMs combined and its bundling of Internet Explorer with Windows). Apple has even run afoul of that at various times (like when it got dinged for its monopolistic behavior regarding e-books; it certainly didn't have an actual monopoly, but that still fell under antitrust regulations).

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by moskie on Friday April 24, 2015 @03:56PM (#9435669)
> Neither of them were or are actually monopolies

"Judge Thomas Penfield Jackson issued his findings of fact on November 5, 1999, which stated that Microsoft's dominance of the x86-based personal computer operating systems market constituted a monopoly" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp...

A company does not have to be the sole supplier in a market to be considered a monopoly in the eyes of the law.

> Apple has even run afoul of that at various times (like when it got dinged for its monopolistic behavior regarding e-books; it certainly didn't have an actual monopoly, but that still fell under antitrust regulations).

But that case didn't just involve Apple. It also involved the oligopoly of book publishers, who worked with Apple to engage in price fixing against Amazon.

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by yellowapple on Friday April 24, 2015 @05:44PM (#9436190)
That still leaves us with Google, which (as far as I know) is not considered a "monopoly" by any measure of the term.

With that said...

> Microsoft's dominance of the x86-based personal computer operating systems market constituted a monopoly

If you read further in the paragraph you quoted, you'll find that Microsoft was specifically engaging in monopolization (i.e. the process of becoming a monopoly), which was the specific reason why it got dinged. It also states the and in there - that they had taken measures to disrupt attempts to counter their monopolization.

This analysis is consistent with the Sherman Antitrust Act (the law under which Microsoft was cited), specifically Section 2: Every person who shall monopolize, or attempt to monopolize, or combine or conspire with any other person or persons, to monopolize any part of the trade or commerce among the several States, or with foreign nations, shall be deemed guilty of a felony [. . . ]". It's also consisted with the Sherman Antitrust Act's intent, as specified by its authors (George Hoar: "... [a person] who merely by superior skill and intelligence...got the whole business because nobody could do it as well as he could was not a monopolist..(but was if) it involved something like the use of means which made it impossible for other persons to engage in fair competition.").

This isn't even mentioning the failure of the court to recognize that there were viable altneratives to Windows that, in their words, "a significant percentage of consumers world-wide could substitute for Intel-compatible PC operating systems without incurring substantial costs". GNU/Linux (which was designed for "Intel-compatible PC"s to begin with), three of the four mainstream BSDs (NetBSD, FreeBSD, and OpenBSD), OS/2, and a variety of other operating systems existed at the time of that ruling. The only way the ruling's rationale would hold true is if they interpreted "Intel-compatible" to mean "Windows-compatible", in which case the ruling is directly applicable to Apple's behavior now (since Apple - like Microsoft then - is attempting to monopolize the application ecosystem of iOS; if Microsoft can get dinged for monopolizing a specific market segment, then so can/should Apple). In this case, Apple is "attempt[ing] to monopolize" smart watches within the the iOS application market (just like how Microsoft "attempt[ed] to monopolize" browsers within the Windows application market). The difference is that Apple's attempts are much more obvious.

Disclaimer: IANAL.

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by moskie on Friday April 24, 2015 @07:33PM (#9436527)
Sorry buddy, you've gone off the deep end here. Microsoft was found in a court of law to have a monopoly in the OS market, and used their market power illegally. Full stop. This is not a controversial fact. You are at best mincing words, and at worst misrepresenting history, to suggest something different.

> That still leaves us with Google, which (as far as I know) is not considered a "monopoly" by any measure of the term.

I don't know how you've come to this conclusion. It is very reasonable to argue that Google has a monopoly on internet search. Whether they are engaging in antitrust is more unclear, but they wield an amount of power in the search market that no other company even gets close to.

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by justonepost on Thursday April 23, 2015 @01:23PM (#9428290)
Yep. This is the long and short of it. Apple is careful not to get monopolies which allows them to be as anti-competitive as they want. Not sure why this got downvoted. Typical HN..
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by Oletros on Thursday April 23, 2015 @01:44PM (#9428422)
What? Doing an anti competitive practice is legal if you don't have a monopoly?
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by moskie on Thursday April 23, 2015 @01:49PM (#9428467)
That is my understanding.

For example, Microsoft got in trouble for pre-installing IE on Windows because they had monopoly in the OS market. If they didn't have that monopoly, they would not have been penalized.

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by brianpgordon on Thursday April 23, 2015 @02:06PM (#9428603)
Having a monopoly might put you under the microscope, but you certainly can't get away with anticompetitive practices like price fixing or wage fixing even if you don't have a monopoly.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by jahewson on Thursday April 23, 2015 @02:13PM (#9428678)
Yes but those are just about the only things which you can't get away with. The US has very weak consumer protection laws in general.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by LordKano on Thursday April 23, 2015 @02:29PM (#9428777)
Collusion. Retail price maintenance. Dividing territories. Exclusive dealing.

These are all anti-competitive behavior that will get one smacked by Federal regulators without being a monopoly.

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by moskie on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:13AM (#9433397)
Can you link to specific examples of companies being found guilty of those things, where the company was not a monopoly, or part of an oligopoly?
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by moskie on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:13AM (#9433393)
Can you link to specific examples of companies being found guilty of things like price fixing and wage fixing, where the company was not a monopoly, or part of an oligopoly?
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by brianpgordon on Friday April 24, 2015 @02:04PM (#9435008)
Well there's this case, which got a lot of HN coverage:

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/01/16/silicon_valley_415m_...

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by moskie on Friday April 24, 2015 @05:36PM (#9436160)
Looks you're correct, thanks. Reading up on this a bit, I was wondering if Apple/Google/Intel/Adobe/etc constituted an oligopoly, but I don't see how that could true in this case. Also reading up on the Sherman Antitrust Act (which is what they were in violation of), the section that applied here does not require a monopoly or oligopoly.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sherman_Antitrust_Act#Elements

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by Oletros on Thursday April 23, 2015 @02:13PM (#9428666)
Pre installing a browser is not an anti competitive practice.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by moskie on Thursday April 23, 2015 @03:41PM (#9429301)
It can be, if the company that does it has a monopoly in the market of operating systems, which would give that company an unfair advantage in the market of browsers. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Microsoft_Corp.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by Oletros on Friday April 24, 2015 @07:26AM (#9432519)
Poor wording for my part, it must say "it is not an anti competitive practice per se"
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by moskie on Friday April 24, 2015 @10:26AM (#9433501)
Right, the fact it is not illegally anticompetitive per se shows that it is an answer to your original question.

> Doing an anti competitive practice is legal if you don't have a monopoly?

A practice being anti-competitive (in a legal sense) depends on the act being done by a company that is a monopoly, or part of an oligopoly.

For example, a company giving their product away for free is not illegal per se. Say, as part of a promotion, in order to get their product in consumer's hands instead of a competitor's product. In a healthy market, this is a valid way to do business.

But, if the company that decides to give their product away for free is a monopoly, and the result of that act is squashing what little competition might exist or is entering the market, then this same act (giving the product away for free) is illegal.

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by Oletros on Saturday April 25, 2015 @04:37AM (#9437683)
Microsoft was not found guilty for giving away IE
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by krschultz on Thursday April 23, 2015 @02:04PM (#9428578)
If you define the market as smart phones. If you define the market as smart watches, Apple could well be dominant in 6 months and this behavior would not be OK.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by Artemis2 on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:37AM (#9427439)
I feel that Google/Apple should have been hit with an antitrust policy already some time ago.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by 31reasons on Thursday April 23, 2015 @01:02PM (#9428143)
I am curious why would Google be in trouble with antitrust ?
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by nilliams on Thursday April 23, 2015 @01:31PM (#9428335)
The EU announced antitrust charges against Google a couple of weeks ago [1]. tl;dr - '[T]he company has given an unfair advantage to its own comparison shopping service ...'

[1] http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/apr/14/european-c...

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by tsunamifury on Thursday April 23, 2015 @03:03PM (#9429032)
No charges were filed and likely never will be. This is merely a list of complaints.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by hellbanner on Thursday April 23, 2015 @02:41PM (#9428877)
Because they dominate search with their PageRank algorithm, they are a huge email provider, online calendar provider, among other services.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by bionsuba on Thursday April 23, 2015 @03:56PM (#9429393)
Probably because they provide the best versions of those services. But hey, no good deed goes unpunished.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by XJOKOLAT on Thursday April 23, 2015 @12:08PM (#9427655)
"Indeed but Apple is aware that the FTC isn't likely to punish them enough that the behavior will be a net negative."

If we believe in what we write, then we should punish them.

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by exelius on Thursday April 23, 2015 @10:57AM (#9427143)
It's also ultimately shitty for consumers, which will drive people away from Apple's products. Microsoft pulled this shit for years with MS Office, and it opened the door for Google.

This behavior may get them in trouble with the FTC, but it's also not likely to be very popular in the market. I get if they want a "premium" experience with the Apple Watch, but they shouldn't block other devices. The Apple Watch should be able to win on its own merits; the wearables space is still small enough that IMO any competition should be welcomed as it drives the whole market forward.

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by kbenson on Thursday April 23, 2015 @01:51PM (#9428479)
That assumes an informed consumer, and what we are discussing is actually Apple's attempt to restrict consumer information.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by sspiff on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:06AM (#9427205)
Exactly. Business isn't a no-holds-barred anything goes anarchy. It's not because we have some free trade that there are no rules what so ever.

Abusing a stranglehold or monopoly will eventually draw the ire of regulators. Just ask Microsoft or the EU.

What is and isn't OK is something that will probably be decided in court. I hope this kind of anti-competitive measures do get some kind of regulation in the app-stores/ecosystems space that large mobile players have crafted over the past few years, because they could easily stiffle competition from their current dominant positions.

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by runjake on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:44AM (#9427486)
Apple doesn't need to ask Microsoft. Apple being convicted monopolists, they are no stranger to litigation.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Inc._litigation#Antitrus...

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by asr on Thursday April 23, 2015 @12:38PM (#9427936)
I upvoted you as you make a good point. But a quick note: you can't be a convicted monopolist. "Monopolization" is illegal, but that requires both monopoly power and anticompetitive conduct. Monopoly power on its own is not illegal (at least theoretically).
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by ahallock on Thursday April 23, 2015 @03:58PM (#9429409)
Anarchy means no rulers, it doesn't mean there are no rules. Maybe eventually it will if people keep perverting the meaning.

> Abusing a stranglehold or monopoly

Apple has a "stranglehold" on what exactly? I think you're just using hyperbolic words.

> I hope this kind of anti-competitive measures do get some kind of regulation

How about a little patience instead? How about not buying Apple products? Let's get the pitchforks out and demand the government punish these companies because they're inconveniencing us, or give it enough time and let consumers sort it out. Look what happened with Internet Explorer. Does it dominate the market anymore?

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by bryanlarsen on Thursday April 23, 2015 @12:36PM (#9427916)
You're allowed to do things like this; you're also allowed to be a de-facto monopoly. You're not allowed to do things like this AND be a monopoly.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by baddox on Thursday April 23, 2015 @01:06PM (#9428169)
I will never understand how "competitive" and "anticompetitive" came to be used interchangeably.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by logfromblammo on Thursday April 23, 2015 @03:16PM (#9429144)
Cutting your prices is competitive. Cutting your competitor's throat is anti-competitive.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by reallyRaoul on Thursday April 23, 2015 @05:50PM (#9430104)
dumping
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by logfromblammo on Friday April 24, 2015 @01:31PM (#9434772)
It took me a little while to figure out that your one-word post meant the practice of selling below cost to gain market share, with the intent to force marginal competitors out of your business and gain pricing power to be used later to make up for the losses.

I am not convinced that this practice is worthy of concern. I don't think that a short-term predatory pricing loss incurred by a dumper can ever be recovered. This opinion is based mostly on the personal belief that the substitution effect is far greater than most economists care to admit, particularly when the potential substitution is to not buy anything at all.

You can't dump alfalfa to bankrupt existing hay growers and then make a killing by raising alfalfa prices once you dominate the market. Why? Farmers will feed their livestock gummy bears[0]. And then they will plant their own damned hay crops at the very next available opportunity. The net result is that you go bankrupt, too, because you took a huge loss right before killing your own market.

[0]http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/09/23/us-usa-cattle-cand...

http://www.naturalnews.com/037351_cattle_candy_marshmallows....

http://money.cnn.com/2012/10/10/news/economy/farmers-cows-ca...

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by _yosefk on Thursday April 23, 2015 @03:21PM (#9429174)
A great point. Perhaps because if "competitive behavior" means striving to win in a competition, and "anti-competitive behavior" means breaking the rules of the competition, hoping to win unfairly, then the former will tend to transform into the latter?
[deleted]
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by enjo on Thursday April 23, 2015 @11:28AM (#9427354)
They did exactly the same sort of thing with Jobs running things. You can find hundreds of examples.

This sort of thing is business as usual at Apple.

Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by kbenson on Thursday April 23, 2015 @12:26PM (#9427814)
What, now we're supposed to give a pass to people and companies that behave horribly and/or illegally just because they have a better product?
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by yellowapple on Thursday April 23, 2015 @10:48PM (#9431154)
"Better" being debatable, of course.
Re:Apple now rejecting apps with Pebble Smartwatch support by kbenson on Friday April 24, 2015 @09:58AM (#9433281)
I agree, I just didn't feel like debating it was worthwhile for the point.