Re:Liblfds, a portable, license-free, lock-free data structu...
by TheLoneWolfling on Thursday April 23, 2015 @09:14AM
(#9426406)
The problem with this approach is that your definition of "reasonable, sane" may not line up with someone else's.
Re:Liblfds, a portable, license-free, lock-free data structu...
by nine_k on Thursday April 23, 2015 @01:44PM
(#9428420)
It's sort of like not to check the values of parameters passed to a function, expecting than only reasonable, sane values will be provided, and no one will try to exploit the function.
This may be a fine assumption for a private function. But for a public interface, be it a function or a license, you have to program defensively.
Be clear here - it is not so much the purpose of licensing which I disagree with (for it fairly closely implements property rights, which I profoundly agree with) but rather the method of implementation - there is a single set of law, decided by others, and we have to obey that law. This violates my idea of freedom.
So with regard to the licensing text on the library, I am attempting to meet the legal needs of users by giving them a carte blanche; they can know their (reasonable, sane) licensing needs will be met, and this I hope simply removes the issue as far as they are concerned, while honouring my ethical views.