That amounts to reducing the number of pirates to a manageable level. The MPAA/RIAA can live with piracy by the members of Slashdot, but if Aunt Tillie gets into it they're screwed.
> Judgements of millions will be issued against people without that money. They won't pay.
If you get a judgement against you, depending on what state you live in your bank account can be frozen or your wages can be garnished. Maybe worse in some states. They don't have to collect millions to hurt you.
>They will be arrested and have another trial (at my/the state's expense) be sentenced to prison.
Charles Dickens, is that you? You don't go to prison for non-payment of debt, unless it's child support or taxes.
>The "deadbeats" might also take a hit on their credit score, but there is nothing anyone wants to buy with credit anymore, so this is not much of a deterrent. Oh no, you mean I can't get a loan on a house that will decrease in value over the 30 years I live in it?
That's a hell of an overstatement, and a hell of an extrapolation from a bursting housing bubble that will be forgotten by most people in 30 years.
You do go to prison when you ignore a court order, however.
Just sayin', it is going to be too costly to society to deter people from committing piracy this way. You may be able to deter businesses (there is no Web 2.0 for-pay piracy app yet), but not individuals.
The best way to deter people from piracy is to listen to them and give them what they want. People want to pay $1 for a high-definition DRM-free download of that just-released movie. The problem is, the industry won't let them pay, so they have to steal instead. It would be hilarious if so many lives weren't being ruined by lawsuits.
The good news is that if you are planning terrorist attacks (via Skype) or distributing child porn (via Tor or Freenet), your chances of being caught are much, much lower than they were in the late nineties. Back then, the only people that needed the strong protection provided by modern file-sharing protocols were people trying to do things that most people would consider illegal. But now, you get that when you call your Mom on Skype or when you are downloading the latest linux ISO -- meaning that the "real criminals" are just noise now. There's nothing suspicious about having no cleartext coming out of your 'net connection anymore.
Suing people for sharing music makes the job of the terrorists much easier. (Can I have my Senate seat now? I'm from Illinois and am willing to pay for it with the money I've saved from downloading The Simpsons every week instead of buying the DVDs.)
Anyway, let's say we implement the system the article describes. Judgements of millions will be issued against people without that money. They won't pay. It will go to collections. They still won't pay. (You can't get blood from a stone.) They will be arrested and have another trial (at my/the state's expense) be sentenced to prison. Except wait, there is no room in the prisons, even for violent criminals. So society will have to build more prisons, at great expense, and pay to house these deadbeat file-sharers. Or, in the real world, they won't be sentenced to prison, and will do community service or something. They won't show up for that, and nobody will be care, because it costs society a lot of money to punish these people. Oh, and there's that whole Constitution thing too.
The "deadbeats" might also take a hit on their credit score, but there is nothing anyone wants to buy with credit anymore, so this is not much of a deterrent. Oh no, you mean I can't get a loan on a house that will decrease in value over the 30 years I live in it? OH NOES.
Basically, there is no way the Content Creators can win by playing the "punish the criminals" game. Society is already tired of it, and the strategy isn't even remotely close to being effective yet.
No, they will just have to adapt. Sites like Hulu probably took a bigger bite out of piracy than the threat of punishment ever will.