Re:The Valuation Boost Needed to Justify YC
by ivankirigin on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @04:21PM
(#9423282)
The two companies are different in lots of ways, this being one of them. We're not disagreeing. You simply rephrased my point that the company needs to be this valuable to match the dilution.
And thanks for finding that PG post, it influenced the thinking here. At the end of the post, we come to the same conclusion: YC is worth it if it makes your company more likely to succeed.
Re:The Valuation Boost Needed to Justify YC
by jacquesm on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @04:12PM
(#9423227)
At some point the nasty matter of 'control' will rear its head and you might regret selling any shares early on. Some shares may turn out to be much more valuable than you ever thought they would be.
Re:The Valuation Boost Needed to Justify YC
by paulsutter on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @07:15PM
(#9424172)
Actually, money losing companies are controlled by their investors, and companies that make money are controlled by management.
This is a pragmatic truth that stems from board dynamics, personal risk tradeoffs for investors, etc. Most of the fears around ownership percentage, board seats, etc, are misplaced.
Re:The Valuation Boost Needed to Justify YC
by beambot on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @04:16PM
(#9423250)
Control is a separate concern that could (indeed) play into how you "justify YC".
I'm just saying: If you use "dollar-value of equity" as the metric to justify YC, OP's calculations are wrong. If you use "percent ownership", then it's fine.
Re:The Valuation Boost Needed to Justify YC
by jacquesm on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @04:52PM
(#9423470)
What I'm getting at, in case it isn't clear that in the end those few shares that you sold cheap can come back to haunt you in later years. So dilute if you have to or want to but be very careful about the terms.
Re:The Valuation Boost Needed to Justify YC
by brudgers on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @05:03PM
(#9423530)
My hunch is that there are worse initial 7% equity holders than YC should control become an issue down the road...which is to say I haven't read about YC screwing people over control, not that founders have nit perceived such actions.
Re:The Valuation Boost Needed to Justify YC
by jacquesm on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @05:35PM
(#9423738)
Absolutely but the next round or the one after that might push you over the 50 border and it need not be YC that does the screwing, that could easily be a later investor.
Re:The Valuation Boost Needed to Justify YC
by brudgers on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @06:15PM
(#9423935)
Of course. I guess there might be soft advantages from YC's participation that reduce the probability of getting into a bad situation, e.g. access to investors less likely to throw founders overboard and a network which may make questionable investor behavior higher profile.
Re:The Valuation Boost Needed to Justify YC
by jacquesm on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @06:17PM
(#9423939)
That is probably a really nice side effect, something akin to a vaccination. Excellent observation.
Re:The Valuation Boost Needed to Justify YC
by neurotech1 on Wednesday April 22, 2015 @06:54PM
(#9424094)
Investors would think twice about "screwing" a YC backed company. PG has clearly stated that they would blacklist VCs for various not-so-ethical practices.
If you're concerned with value, then the % you own is not the only key factor. I.e. 10% of a $1B company is more valuable than 50% of a $100M company. PG's equity equation (the source of 1/(1-n)) deals with value: http://paulgraham.com/equity.html