Re:A very clever idea to enforce copyright with minimal laws...
by jacquesm on Saturday November 14, 2009 @05:18PM
(#942233)
This is fatally flawed, there is such a thing as a defense fund. All the 'cheaters' could pledge to each other to help out in case of a fine.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A very clever idea to enforce copyright with minimal laws...
by tptacek on Saturday November 14, 2009 @10:18PM
(#942554)
Yeah. That's what's going to happen. Uh-huh.
Let's modify the scheme just a tiny little bit:
"We're going to sue the first 1000 people we see violating our copyrights starting at 8:00, and we're not going to count people who we find during discovery accepted money from a 'defense fund'".
I'm pretty sure that leaves 99.999% of the original target population to sue.
Re:A very clever idea to enforce copyright with minimal laws...
by tptacek on Sunday November 15, 2009 @03:16PM
(#943286)
I forgot if that case ever resolved itself fully, but, isn't $3000 like less than 1% of what she wound up liable for?
Re:A very clever idea to enforce copyright with minimal laws...
by jacquesm on Sunday November 15, 2009 @05:21PM
(#943441)
Yes, but that wasn't the point, defense funds exist, they're being used, and it won't take much to institutionalize them where people will simply set them up pre-emptively.
Such indemnification schemes can be made illegal by the authorities though.
It's a reverse lottery, if you play and you end up losing then the pot covers your losses.
Re:A very clever idea to enforce copyright with minimal laws...
by tptacek on Sunday November 15, 2009 @09:05PM
(#943775)
What I said was, even if defense funds actually happened --- and the only example you have is a large organization defraying a tiny fraction of the legal costs for a hugely publicized case --- they wouldn't interfere with this recovery strategy.
Re:A very clever idea to enforce copyright with minimal laws...
by Daniel_Newby on Saturday November 14, 2009 @10:02PM
(#942542)
Then the plaintiff can follow the money trail and fry them all.